On Red Mage melee...

[cidbahamut]

Not in the picture above.

Look again. You're either blind, or intentionally ignoring what is plain for all to see.

Do you really not understand what a logical fallacy is? You have given NO reason that those numbers were fake besides either 1) You say so, 2) your BG friends say so, or 3) Because Sam is a DD.

That is not logic OR reason, that is your personal opinion being treated as a fact.

How about inadequate testing environment documentation? I saw no gearsets listed for that alla parse, so until I see otherwise I'm assuming everyone was wielding ash clubs and wearing bikinis. That's not exactly compelling evidence for your case.

[Aurara]

KC rdm sucks? really?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U3XfsPLAr3A

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5SVTg...eature=related

[Rearden]

So instead of arguing what we were before (A RDM can do 80% of a GREAT DD in a merit party) we're now arguing that a RDM can out DD a naked MNK?

safefacegranite.jpg

[Supersun]

In 2006, yes, Rdm KC sucked on anything more then a decent challenge. No amount of accuracy and sushi in the world is going to get that D rated weapon to land on even trash mobs

[Aurara]

Seems like it!

[Aurara]

In 2006, yes, Rdm KC sucked on anything more then a decent challenge. No amount of accuracy and sushi in the world is going to get that D rated weapon to land on even trash mobs

Actually sushi and acc gear would so you're wrong again sir.

[Neisan_Quetz]

Assuming 75 rdm/rng capped club with no merits+sushi, the gear shown in pic, he would have had at least... 82% accuracy assuming a T mob with 330 evasion. Of course, I have no clue what evasion Jnun has.

[Hyrist]

KC rdm sucks? really?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U3XfsPLAr3A

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5SVTg...eature=related

Yes, it sucks. Abyssea might break the mechaics, due to how crap broken Abyssea is. But the Attercotts are a miserable refrence for 75. Try hitting anything above T with that tactic 75. I have. Wif wif wif wif wif wif wif wif.

Still, it'd be fun to see how Kittycatty measures up against Zafire, though.

Out of courosity Aurara, what atmas was Kitty using?

[Aurara]

Yes, it sucks. Abyssea might break the mechaics, due to how crap broken Abyssea is. But the Attercotts are a miserable refrence for 75. Try hitting anything above T with that tactic 75. I have. Wif wif wif wif wif wif wif wif.

Still, it'd be fun to see how Kittycatty measures up against Zafire, though.

Out of courosity Aurara, what atmas was Kitty using?

I have no idea, i searchrd RDM KC and those came up. Your gear obviously is terrible because my rdm at 75 could have melee gear good enough to have decent acc with KC.

[Supersun]

Actually sushi and acc gear would so you're wrong again sir.

Maybe against that easy prey spider in that video, but against an actual exp monster (which is what I meant by trash mob)

Against Greater Colibri I calculate that a Rdm/Rng would be landing the KClub at ~70% rate eating sushi and wearing accuracy gear (with ~15% haste from gear).

Not as bad as I thought but still not going to beat Blau/Joy at the time. Not even close. Biggest deal breaker is going to be the lack of attack making the TP phase virtually worthless