On Red Mage melee...

[Seriha]

I'm totally a BG shark because I call people on their BS right?

Nah, it's more the floundering in their butthurt du jour thread. Woe is FFXI, someone with a different opinion said something. ATTACK!

[Aurara]

The only floundering is people without a logical counter argument to what i'm saying

[Neisan_Quetz]

All I see is a parse of Rdm/Nin versus 2 dds who gain no benefit from subbing Nin.

Oh, and having another Rdm hasting everyone because one of them is too busy 'dd'ing'.

Then I see war/nin using Vorpal Blade with bergressor merits, that's especially confounding... something about outparsed a thf/war not using SA or TA WS? Really.

EDIT: And now I learn he took out the information including Lurkers.

[Rearden]

Just to clarify, you are saying that parse includes a BB MNK, and a SAM/NIN using Gekko against Mamool, correct?

And that the data for Lurkers has been removed?

Also, THF WS/SA/TA have been removed?

WAR using vorpal blade?

SAM subbing crap subjob?

Is that all correct?



And do you see where I'm going?

[Aurara]

They dont care, they are just going to come up with another ad hominem attack against us, and continue with the "RDM melee crusade" no matter how much parse data argues otherwise.

[Thunderlips]

Naked Mnk > Melee RDM

That's a link to a parse of a MNK with only a weapon beating out a well geared RDM. You can scroll up a bit to see the RDM's gear. The parse is against a Doomed so neither the MNK nor the RDM are getting a weapon type bonus against the mob.

[Aurara]

game over, lol

[Bagel]

It has been over, one side just didn't know it yet, and likely still doesn't.

[Hyrist]

Yeah, I remember that moronic KI parse. I also remember tearing it to shreads.

Also, as stated before, you can call it over, when SE removes RDM's sword and dagger skill form the game.

[cidbahamut]

Wait, didn't you just hold up a parse waving it around shouting "See? This proves it, we did 80% of a SAM's damage!" not two pages ago? And now parses don't count...