Best mythic ws's?

[Lisotte]

Hey, I just finished floor 100 on my first, main job (PUP). I got the awesome mythic ws, Stringing Pummel.

Figured that I might as well go and unlock the mythic ws's for other jobs, at least for jobs I have, and/or the good ws's.

What are the good, competitive mythic ws's? I've got sch and war; but in the future might start leveling other jobs, possibly based on which have the best mythic ws's (nyzul was a pain as it was the first piece of content where I was the organising person to get people together for runs).

[Aarahs]

Dragoon's at least was competitive. Don't remember how it matches with stardiver now.

[Lisotte]

Dragoon's at least was competitive. Don't remember how it matches with stardiver now.

Ironically that was the 1 I knew apart from pup and sch's ws's that were supposed to be good.

[Demon6324236]

In Aby Drake>Star outside Aby Drake<Star so far as I know, however I hear Drake is still better on low levels outside as well. As for other WSs, I don't know much outside of DRG & PUP being awesome.

[TMG]

A lot of them aren't quite as good as they used to be now compared to the new merit WS's, and just about every Empyrean WS if you have any or plan to in the future. If you do a lot of Abyssea still, that's a whole different ballgame since critical WS's are king in there. WAR's mythic WS for example is beat by Raging Rush inside of Abyssea, and Upheaval outside, so their mythic WS isn't particularly worth using. MNK's mythic WS is actually quite good in Abyssea since it crits and should beat everything else except Empyrean. BST RNG and COR have some decent elemental WS's for building amber lights (gold box farming) if you use proper gear and/or atmas. Melee WHM's (yeah I know lolmeleewhm, it's fun sometimes) have a very handy mythic WS, it returns a good chunk of MP so they should never really have to rest and can keep on clubbing things. RDM's is okay if you ever find yourself wielding a sword outside Abyssea (campaign) because they get shafted on all the good sword WS's natively. Some others like DNC and SAM can only really be useful for opening level 3 skillchains. Ultimately, some are situational, others are useless, and very few really shine nowadays. MNK DRG and PUP probably have the "best" WS's, inside of Abyssea with crit atmas. COR's can also be pretty fun for XP parties with the right atmas if you have a Joyeuse for gaining TP, and you can use cheap bronze bullets without hurting your damage since it's elemental. I can't say I've ever had a reason to melee on SCH so I don't have that one unlocked and can't offer any insight.

[Karbuncle]

Well, I Can tell you off the top of my head how much most of them will get any realistic use...

WHM - Restore MP, Obvious Situational Uses
BLM - ... Uh.
RDM - Used to be pretty good, Requisc/Chant Replace it in most situations.
THF - Garbage, Should never be used.
WAR - See THF
MNK - Good in Abyssea so long as you don't have Victory Smite.
PLD - Used to be awesome, Not so much now, Everything Resists it
DRK - Pretty Lame
BST - Pretty lame
BRD - Might be decent with 99 Carw.
SAM - Good for Darkness Skillchain?
RNG - Nope
NIN - Nope
DRG - Pretty decent, Stardiver > Outside as stated above.
SMN - I use it for Skillchains... Sekka > Garland > Shatter = Gravitation. Yup... Lowers DEF, But only 12.5%, Less than Shell Crusher, the WS we get... IDK, 40 levels earlier.
BLU - Nope.
COR - Nope
PUP - Epic.
DNC - Nope.
SCH - Nope.

[Theytak]

Well, I Can tell you off the top of my head how much most of them will get any realistic use...

WHM - Restore MP, Obvious Situational Uses
BLM - ... Uh.
RDM - Used to be pretty good, Requisc/Chant Replace it in most situations.
THF - Garbage, Should never be used.
WAR - See THF
MNK - Good in Abyssea so long as you don't have Victory Smite.
PLD - Used to be awesome, Not so much now, Everything Resists it
DRK - Pretty Lame
BST - Pretty lame
BRD - Might be decent with 99 Carw.
SAM - Good for Darkness Skillchain?
RNG - Nope
NIN - Nope
DRG - Pretty decent, Stardiver > Outside as stated above.
SMN - I use it for Skillchains... Sekka > Garland > Shatter = Gravitation. Yup... Lowers DEF, But only 12.5%, Less than Shell Crusher, the WS we get... IDK, 40 levels earlier.
BLU - Nope.
COR - Nope
PUP - Epic.
DNC - Nope.
SCH - Nope.

I agree for the most part, except;
WAR - used to have a use as the go-to Mighty Strikes WS. The Upheaval came around.
SAM, BLU, and DNC (and BRD, as I've seen from the amazing melee brd and salleted hero of siren) are all pretty much relegated to setting up self SCs.
BLM - while not necessarily strong, having it available greatly increases your ability to perform shenanigans. VIIIIDDDOOOOOO
COR - Basically a far less potent, darkness based Wildfire, that, if nothing else, is complementary to QD spammage on physical resistant opponents if wildfire is unavailable.

that said, I feel many of them are worth getting purely because they look fucking cool.

[Zhronne]

Well, I Can tell you off the top of my head how much most of them will get any realistic use...

WHM - Restore MP, Obvious Situational Uses
BLM - ... Uh.
RDM - Used to be pretty good, Requisc/Chant Replace it in most situations.
THF - Garbage, Should never be used.
WAR - See THF
MNK - Good in Abyssea so long as you don't have Victory Smite.
PLD - Used to be awesome, Not so much now, Everything Resists it
DRK - Pretty Lame
BST - Pretty lame
BRD - Might be decent with 99 Carw.
SAM - Good for Darkness Skillchain?
RNG - Nope
NIN - Nope
DRG - Pretty decent, Stardiver > Outside as stated above.
SMN - I use it for Skillchains... Sekka > Garland > Shatter = Gravitation. Yup... Lowers DEF, But only 12.5%, Less than Shell Crusher, the WS we get... IDK, 40 levels earlier.
BLU - Nope.
COR - Nope
PUP - Epic.
DNC - Nope.
SCH - Nope.

Uhm, aren't you being a bit too negative?
Actually, tbh, what you described is most likely the real situation as of today.
But there have been days when the situation was different from this.
Back at level 75 some of those WS which are shit today used to be at least decent back then, if anything a good option to open/close SC.
For instance:

NIN: it sucks, but sometimes while soloing I used Blade: Kamu to stick its accuracy down effect, which stacks with Kurayami.

BST: Back then BSTs were hanging out with lots of CHR gear for Charm, and they had been screaming for a CHR mod based WS for ages. Primal Rend was just that. With lots of CHR gear and some mab one, Primal Rend was actually a decent WS. Of course, those were different times and today there just is no place for it I guess.

THF - In times where only a few players had Mandau and there were no Rudra's Storm and Extenterator, Mandalic Stab was a decent option if anything for SC purposes.

WAR - Used to be pretty nice in some setups?

SAM - Always sucked, if anything it sucked even more at 75 since the typical GKT was Hagun, with its really low base damage. Only use of Rana was to self SC Darkness, I think.

DNC - Uh... it's never been great, but it was "okaysh" at 75?

[Karbuncle]

P.S - Try not to take what i'm saying as Rude, Even though it sounds it, Its mostly brutal sarcasm I don't hate you.

Uhm, aren't you being a bit too negative?

Not even sorta Kinda. Most if not all Mythic WS's are Pretty useless. They all have some Quasi-Useful Additional Effect, But as far as any realistic uses, No, Very Few of them are any good, Most of them had some uses at 75, But as of now, They're pretty terrible. Since the OP Was looking for relevant, 2012 Information, i left out any uses they may have had back at 75, Since thats irrelevant.

NIN: it sucks, but sometimes while soloing I used Blade: Kamu to stick its accuracy down effect, which stacks with Kurayami.

The Accuracy Down is nice, But chances are wasting a WS on this for 300 DMG instead of doing a 3k~5k Hi or Shun will probably balance out in favor of Shun/Hi. Since Killing it faster is probably going to be better for your survivability.

BST: Back then BSTs were hanging out with lots of CHR gear for Charm, and they had been screaming for a CHR mod based WS for ages. Primal Rend was just that. With lots of CHR gear and some mab one, Primal Rend was actually a decent WS. Of course, those were different times and today there just is no place for it I guess.

Back in the day? Yah, But this isn't 2007 again, And I'm pretty sure he's asking for relevant information, not outdated information. Hell, Back at 75 I had a Primal Rend set, And it was lovely, Just not good today.

THF - In times where only a few players had Mandau and there were no Rudra's Storm and Extenterator, Mandalic Stab was a decent option if anything for SC purposes.

Which, Again, Is not pertinent today. Even back at 75, Shark Bite was generally better than Mandalic...

WAR - Used to be pretty nice in some setups?

I think we're seeing a patter now, "Used too", Even back then, It was really only good as a Mighty Strikes WS

SAM - Always sucked, if anything it sucked even more at 75 since the typical GKT was Hagun, with its really low base damage. Only use of Rana was to self SC Darkness, I think.

Its good for Setting up Self Darkness, But I think there are better WS combination that will do more damage, Even if its just getting you Frag or Grav.

DNC - Uh... it's never been great, but it was "okaysh" at 75?

IDK About it at 75 unfortunately, nor do i know much about DNC, But i think Evisc/Rudra's Skillchaining replaces the Phyr/Evisc Skillchain if you have Thwast. Otherwise, I think its still good for that Darkness thing.

[Eri]

IDK About it at 75 unfortunately, nor do i know much about DNC, But i think Evisc/Rudra's Skillchaining replaces the Phyr/Evisc Skillchain if you have Thwast. Otherwise, I think its still good for that Darkness thing.

As Dnc Main is can say by 75 in Merrit Situation (Colibri) my Pyrics Hit around 1kish (Same as DE)

Now with 99 Spikes are 1.3kish Pyric (Spikes as in can hit way lower without capped Attack)
DE isnt compareable.

Also if you take Rudra's in account.

You can: Pyric > Eviscrevation > Dark > Rudras > Dark Lv2

So its far from Pointless. It will do as 'good' as Excentrator (lvl5)... bit lower maybe.... but with better SC possiblitys.