Originally Posted by Mirage

But that doesn't hold true for all the magian weapons. Some fire path weapons are not the strongest, why should these be more expensive? What happens to your effort/reward ratio now?

I brought this up before but he just trolled and said that I should have picked a different weapon. He has no arguments. He has no dog in the fight. I hope that SE sees the only ones against this being changed are Fupa and themselves, and neither have brought anything of value to the discussion. All they've said is no. That's not good enough.

Originally Posted by Camiie

I brought this up before but he just trolled and said that I should have picked a different weapon. He has no arguments. He has no dog in the fight. I hope that SE sees the only ones against this being changed are Fupa and themselves, and neither have brought anything of value to the discussion. All they've said is no. That's not good enough.

Not once have I said "I am against it". I have been saying you guys are just lazy lol. And explained how it doesn't "need" to be changed. All you guys see is "THIS MUST BE CHANGED. NO QUESTIONS OR REASONING. IT HAS TO BE CHANGED BECAUSE IT IS TOO PRICEY AND HARD TO GET 55 GEODES".

If you haven't seen any reasoning in this thread, it's because you haven't actually been reading any other posts than your own.

Originally Posted by Fupafighter

Not once have I said "I am against it". I have been saying you guys are just lazy lol. And explained how it doesn't "need" to be changed. All you guys see is "THIS MUST BE CHANGED. NO QUESTIONS OR REASONING. IT HAS TO BE CHANGED BECAUSE IT IS TOO PRICEY AND HARD TO GET 55 GEODES".

I have 2 fire weapons. I farmed and bought the geodes needed to 99'em. It was easy as hell for me, though annoying due to relying on Firesdays. This does not, however, mean that flame geodes shouldnt be changed. A flawed system is still flawed no matter how easy some players may find it.

Oh, and one more thing: either make a legit point against the change, or kindly shut the hell up. You're arguing for no other reason then to argue.

Grow up.

Doesn't Twashtar follow Ukon's path as well? I guess if that's the case, I'll start inviting Twash DNCs to DD situations over SAM, DRK etc. since the path of their empy proves how strong the weapon is.

Originally Posted by Fupafighter

Not once have I said "I am against it".

Then why are you even here?

I have been saying you guys are just lazy lol.

Ah right. You're here for trolling and unprovoked personal attacks.

And explained how it doesn't "need" to be changed.

Well hell, nothing in FFXI "needs" to be changed.

All you guys see is "THIS MUST BE CHANGED. NO QUESTIONS OR REASONING. IT HAS TO BE CHANGED BECAUSE IT IS TOO PRICEY AND HARD TO GET 55 GEODES".

No that's all YOU see. Stop projecting.

People have pointed out how frequently other types of weather occur in relation to fire. Hell there's charts that show it if you care to look, which I'm sure you don't. You claimed that fire weapons are some of the best weapons, and we've told you that that isn't always the case. It's actually a small fraction of them that are markedly superior to other options. That hardly justifies all fire based weapons to be more difficult or expensive to obtain than their other-element counterparts.

A TP Bonus Great Katana is far more useful than a TP Bonus Great Axe. Why doesn't the GK require more Weapon Skills than the GA if time and effort involved are based on usefulness? And don't get me started on WoE weapons and the lack of balance there.

Originally Posted by Camiie

fire weapons are hard

when does everything have to be equal? what is the reasoning behind your constant replies to an obvious troll, besides to muckrake yourself and complain about something that wasn't meant to be quick or equal to the other alternatives.

if you're building the dagger, then get an aluh jambiyah. if you're building the axe, that sucks. but in all honesty, there are other solutions, you're just upset that the best (and soloable) solution is a timesink.

wake up, you are playing an mmorpg.

Originally Posted by Plasticleg

if you're building the dagger, then get an aluh jambiyah.

I did.

if you're building the axe, that sucks. but in all honesty, there are other solutions, you're just upset that the best (and soloable) solution is a timesink.

Atar III is what I'm making. That's the Avatar Perpetuation/Blood Pact Ability Delay Staff that is used with Ifrit. It is no better or worse than the equivalent weapon for any other avatar, yet it is far more expensive and time consuming to create.

Hell, I would get two aluh jambiyas if they weren't rare.

Originally Posted by Mirage

Hell, I would get two aluh jambiyas if they weren't rare.

aluh + eva dagger sounds more like something that you could attain