Another angle of argument would be this:

Would you rather evade 7% more hits and fight the mob for x minutes?
Or kill the mob in half the time?

Arguably, killing a mob in half the time is evading 50% of it's hits right?

I mean that's an oversimplification sure, but there's a lot of truth in the example.

Quote Originally Posted by Tsukino_Kaji View Post
Therefore with capped closed possision I could drop gear for something with more potent DD stats while still maintianing tanking. CP also has emity, which makes it a good thing.
You could do that, sure, you could also merit No Foot Rise and learn to use your Finishing moves better; perhaps stun more frequently, that's a really good way to evade attacks. Or Merit Sabre Dance for when you have support.

Still doesn't fix the fact that you're likely going to be close to cap on accuracy and evasion whether of not you have closed position.

Closed Position Does not give emnity btw, been checking and double checking, it's not listed anywhere that it does.