Weather Effect Atma Adjustment

[Godofgods]

Iv been wondering about this since the release of Hero's of Abyssea. Finally getting around to mentioning it.

Why do atmas such as Atma of the Earth Wyrm (Gain full benefit of Earthsday/earth weather bonuses) and Atma of the Scarlet Wing (Gain full benefit of Windsday/wind weather bonuses) effect everything except trial weapons?

By the atmas definition it should count for ToM. I was quite excited for these atmas the very first time i saw them, because i thought how great they work together with ToM weapons. I was highly disappointed when i found out they didn't help.

And the thing about it is, it wouldn't make things 'easier'. You can still do trials in Aby on specific elemental days. This only increases how often you can do it. So it wont make it easier, only make it take less time. Similar to the adjustment making dyna once a day.

And theirs an atma for each element. So how about allowing us to actually use them for something important? (granted I'm done all my trials weapons, but id still like to see it)

[Nawesemo]

Gain full benefit of weather, only thing is, there's no stinkin weather!

[Khajit]

What are Scholars for 200 Bob?

[Nawesemo]

What are Scholars for 200 Bob?

Embrava pimpin.


Oooooo low blow?

[Demon6324236]

Embrava pimpin.


Oooooo low blow?

You didn't understand what he said apparently.

[Nawesemo]

You didn't understand what he said apparently.

Tough crowd eh.....

[hiko]

What are Scholars for 200 Bob?

scholar's spells doesn't affect trial weapons.

imo trials need the monster to have weather status.

[Daniel_Hatcher]

Iv been wondering about this since the release of Hero's of Abyssea. Finally getting around to mentioning it.

Why do atmas such as Atma of the Earth Wyrm (Gain full benefit of Earthsday/earth weather bonuses) and Atma of the Scarlet Wing (Gain full benefit of Windsday/wind weather bonuses) effect everything except trial weapons?

By the atmas definition it should count for ToM. I was quite excited for these atmas the very first time i saw them, because i thought how great they work together with ToM weapons. I was highly disappointed when i found out they didn't help.

And the thing about it is, it wouldn't make things 'easier'. You can still do trials in Aby on specific elemental days. This only increases how often you can do it. So it wont make it easier, only make it take less time. Similar to the adjustment making dyna once a day.

And theirs an atma for each element. So how about allowing us to actually use them for something important? (granted I'm done all my trials weapons, but id still like to see it)

It doesn't even remotely imply that unless you've never obtained an Obi, and even then it doesn't.

PS. Yes, it would make it even easier. In no way would it not. 5 instead of 1 makes it EASIER.

[Kristal]

scholar's spells doesn't affect trial weapons.

imo trials need the monster to have weather status.

SE needs to give RDM lvl 50+ spells to inflict weather effects on monsters
Ofcourse, we all known GEO will get it as an aoe sphere effect from a deployed effect, or an entirely new job is added for it.

[Godofgods]

It doesn't even remotely imply that unless you've never obtained an Obi, and even then it doesn't.

Example:
Trial 2006: ■Defeat a set number of experience-yielding monsters under the prescribed weather conditions (earth), or on the corresponding day of the week.

Atma of the Earth Wyrm: Gain full benefit of Earthsday/earth weather bonuses

It kinda does imply that..