Quote Originally Posted by Sagian View Post
Then why does it work 95% of the time?

I'm not trying to be obtuse, but if someone else has hate, and I'm hitting the mob, and they're hitting the mob, and I'm doing WS's, and they're doing WS's, I might get hate for a moment, but I'm unable to lock hate. If I throw a Cure IV on the person getting hit, I have the mobs undivided attention, at least for a while.
I highly doubt it works 50% of the time let alone 95% of the time assuming you have decent DDs.

On anything that isn't strong to physical damage my WAR averages 250+ a hit not counting crits or widowmaker's bonus, my MNK does 150ish per punch on average and gets 2 cycles to every 3 a PLD gets, keep in mind that's 4 hits vs. 3 hits not counting DA or kick attacks. That means I will be capping/recapping CE/VE hate faster than PLD even if they spam Cure IV on me unless there is 0 ways for me to mitigate any of the damage I'm taking i.e. no shadows, counters, evasion, parries, guards.

This is why a PLD can't keep up once a DD caps hate they can keep it capped much easier than PLD, this sounds bad but at the same time from a design stand point it sounds correct, it means a DD has to hold back or they will die because the PLD won't be tanking. But there is the real problem DDs aren't as squishy as they used to be.