dev1069 Phantom Roll Effect Adjustments feedback

[Vagrua]

Just thought I'd share my opinions on the roll adjustments. By all means, posts what you also think of them. My views:

Healer's Roll will likely not even be considered in a Corsair's arsenal unless it exceeds the current Cure Potency cap of White Mages curing said player with the roll on.

Gallant's Roll would also need to break the pdt/mdt cap in order to even be considered to me. I can see this roll being extremely useful otherwise for tanks.

Drachen Roll, I can see being useful for a pet burn party maybe.

Puppet's Roll, idk what to really think of. It's one of those rolls I could see being useful if Corsair had an ability like Bard's Pianissimo.

Warlock's Roll is something I still can't really see being used. The boost is just too small to me.

Beast Roll looks good.

Choral Roll same as beasts.

I think you could have pushed Dancer's Roll more, but again that's just me.

[Seha]

Even if healer's roll exceeds cap it's worthless. You need to place it on the dds as it is potency received. There's no reason at all to dump reall dd rolls for that.
I see gallant as useful for soloing(like dyna or something), but that's it until we get a third roll slot(and even then the best idea in most cases would be to do chaos-tact-miser, or sam).

[Kristal]

Drachen Roll, I can see being useful for a pet burn party maybe.

Puppet's Roll, idk what to really think of. It's one of those rolls I could see being useful if Corsair had an ability like Bard's Pianissimo.

COR always had these rolls, they simply swapped the jobs and increased the effect a bit. I think they did this to actually match the pets to the roll effect. You needed a DRG to properly boost an automaton's magic, or a PUP to boost a DRG's wyvern. Breath attacks are affected by HP (and EMA?), not MAB or MACC as far as I know.

[Greatguardian]

Gallant is a Phalanx effect rather than -DT%, if that makes any difference. It does stack with Phalanx iirc.

[Tsukino_Kaji]

I bet the first thing on everyone's mind when they logged in to look was, "Here somes the miser's nerf."

[cidbahamut]

Healer's roll went from niche to absolutely worthless. Kind of sad really.

[heartslaught]

Looking at these values, they seem to be the non supercharged values (looking at the values listed, this is a dead give away). Any chance of seeing the super charged values?

[Huevriel]

Healer's Roll -
Thank you for making this not apply to dancing. However, was satisfied as MP Healing.

Gallant's Roll-
This GREATLY helps solo parry skill ups. Thank you SE for answering my prayers. The fact that this stacks with Phalanx ----> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kwT702zhiRI
This is my all time favorite part of this COR-date.

Drachen Roll <--> Puppet Roll
Smart move. I approve.

Boosts to other rolls-
Boosted choral roll is pretty OP. Not complaining though, as I'm sure it's mostly situational and most bandwagon-COR wont use/buy it. Also something I'll use during parry skill ups. (see link above).

All around. Way to go SE!

[Seha]

With the adjustment to healing effects, Healer's roll now makes sense. But still not worth using over dd rolls in 90% of situations.

[cidbahamut]

What situations would it be used in?