Offhand for almace

[Prothscar]

Yes that's the issue, it shouldn't have much of a damage difference. The only difference that should be apparent on this parse should be a difference between weaponskill and melee attack frequency, but there's a major difference in overall damage and spell frequency as well. This does not make sense and does not match possible parameters if both swords had 100 fights each under the same conditions.

I do believe that the difference would be far less, perhaps opposite (but can't say for sure, only with decent certainty) if this information were more clear.

Would have to be a very high level variance, and would have had to have been a large amount of high level crawlers toward the Khanda rather than the Shamshir. Unless things have changed from the 75 days for monster stat scaling, differences between stats for 3-4 levels are not very severe.

Unfortunately this lends itself to what I have been saying about parses.

While it's appreciated that you took the time, and some groundwork has been laid (which correlates with my own calculations a couple of pages back), I don't see this being taken as much of critical evidence in the Khanda's favor.