New Weaponskill! Its not -Awful-

[Kitkat]

I'll agree that Mercy and Rudra destroys it. With appropriate atma/gear set it still does 4.6~5k but I remember seeing evis as high as 5.5-6k with supporting atma. Outside it definitely does far better than evisceration. In sky on Aura Statues I saw up to 3.3k Exenterator, but rarely broke 2.9k with evisceration. Mercy still went as high as 3.9k and I didn't bother comparing rudras after that since I already knew the outcome there also. Unstacked I saw 1.6~2.5k. Hard to love it, but at the same time I don't exactly hate it.

Anyone by chance notice the SC properties for this? I remember Requiscate>Exenterator doing fragmentation, but that was about all I had time to check out before my friend logged for the night.

[Byrth]

http://wiki.bluegartr.com/bg/Exenterator

I've been updating it as I go. The Skillchain properties are pretty unfortunate for Dancer.

[Karbuncle]

Yeah it's not an end all be all WS. Evisc easily beats it in Abyssea and rudra/mercy absolutely destroy it when stacked. Outside is where it shines.

Are we sure? I tested it, Seemed impressive even in Abyssea.

In retrospect, though, I think i made a mistake, And I'm prone to terrible mistakes.

I was in Abyssea testing it on my Brothers character... his Gear isn't amazing, just what we had on the Test server... no WS Gear either, but his WS were averaging 3.5k+, I think my peak was about 4.3k Or something with no SA/TA (he was THF/WAR) (EYEBALL GO)

4.6 or something with the SA, but it died before all hits landed

Was on the Mobs in Altep that wander around where Conflux 2 is, This is where i think i made the mistake, they take more damage when casting... I don't think they were all casting when i WS'd but that might be where I'm fudging the numbers, I'm leaning toward this heavily.

Either way, I was impressed with it in Abyssea, and out... What were your findings? I read all of Byrths, interesting to see yours

[Kitkat]

Well, I was fighting dolls and this is one of the WS I got with trick attack, but I think there was a ta proc in there. Outside of abyssea it was a fairly consistent 3.2k~3.3k stacked with SA against Aura Statues for me. Downside is, I think I read somewhere on bg that there may be less than desirable returns on high def mobs.

[Insaniac]

So far no one has found an attack penalty for exenterator.

I'm nowhere near as mathy as byrth and I was only comparing unstacked exent vs. evisc. Stacked they should be a bit closer. I don't have any concrete numbers unstacked but exent was doing 2.5-3k and that's a lowball for my eviscerations which can easily go up to 5k unstacked and average 3.5k. Both with Apoc RR and GH. I had +72 AGI in gear which is about 10-12 short of the max possible.

Also the Clionids you were messing with do take extra damage while casting and on top of that are weak to piercing.

[Karbuncle]

Also the Clionids you were messing with do take extra damage while casting and on top of that are weak to piercing.

That was my strong assumption.

I only toyed with it for a little while... Skyrim's got my attention. Fun WS, looks cool and all.

[Calatilla]

Slightly off-topic but has anyone managed to get the ws to work from a macro? So far I've only been able to manually select it. When i add it to a macro I get an error message.

[Insaniac]

I haven't had any problems.

[Kitkat]

/ws "Exenterator" <t>

Works just fine for me from macro unless misspelling it.

[Calatilla]

/ws "Exenterator" <t>

Works just fine for me from macro unless misspelling it.

That's how my macro is but for some reason it fails to execute. All other ws's work fine, just not this one.