I thought the idea of cover as a trait in the original post was an interesting idea. I also agree that shield bash (weapon bash as well) should be adjusted. Would it be possible to have ...Bash JA work like charges kinda the way a SCH has charges?
I thought the idea of cover as a trait in the original post was an interesting idea. I also agree that shield bash (weapon bash as well) should be adjusted. Would it be possible to have ...Bash JA work like charges kinda the way a SCH has charges?
Actually, I do like the idea of Cover being changed into a Job Trait, as it's too much of a hassle to use for only 30sec~ when the person you use it on doesn't always sit still so you can actually cover them...
This change would make people more alert and stop running around like chickens with their heads cut off.
The downside to this though is if it is a 100% proc, it could be game breaking for certain events. Black mages and Samurai, etc. could idle behind the Paladin without worry of beig harmed by any Non-Area Effecting attacks, etc..
At the very least I think reducing the Cover recast to 1~1.5min would be a bit more fair along with adjusting the angle of degree to where the target you wish to Cover has to be at to be Covered. If this were a smaller recastable ability it will also make it more commonly used enough to encourage players to actually stop running from the defending Paladin's protection.
Another thing Paladin is going to require soon is Cure V as Cure IV can no longer keep up with the larger spikes of damage dealt to players now. Atleast by level 99 it should be considered once the content has been properly tested enough to make a successful debate on if it's still needed or not, however... As it stands now, Paladin to some extent requires the Cure V assistance incase they need to toss out a couple heals on their allies should the situation be grim with a follow-up Cure IV on theirself for that extra hate generation and still restore enough HP to last over until they can get another Cure or so in there.
Cure V is completely debatable though, but shouldn't in any way be game breaking atleast.
As for Shield Bash recast reduction being lowered to 10~15 seconds, I am not sure that will be concidered. Not that low atleast as the proc is 99% with the exception of select NM that either have high resistance to Stun or are immune to it; Also the duration is rather long on average. It would be more reasonable to have it at 2min30sec recast at most, 1min00sec minimal.
Paladin does need some work now though as they have lost the ability to tank most of the NM in the game, but I expect this to be temporarily until the level 99 content is released. I love the ideas still that everyone has submitted here still, let's keep up the brainstorming guys!
Last edited by Raka; 03-25-2011 at 05:26 PM.
I can see from most of these posts that any real change we can all agree on for sure is something fixing/updating Cover.
Reducing cast time doesn't solve the hate control issue, as hate can spin around between DDs and it makes it difficult to keep attention on one, even more so with a limited time to use it's ability.
In the sense of Cover, I still believe making it a trait is what would work best. It is on at all times, as long as other party members are behind the paladin, they get the effect. but wait, wouldnt everyone just stand by the paladin and no one else takes damage? adjust it so that you make the paladin have to do something by moving around to who needs it. instead of it just being behind the paladin, make it where you have to be directly behind the paladin, in sense. If two people are behind the paladin, if Person A is behind Paladin, and Person B is behind Person A, Person B does not gain Cover effect, since the paladin is not Directly in front of them. This way the paladin has to move to each person.
This would be the smallest fix as even the biggest damage (A brewing DD doing 15k+ dmg in a WS) can be protected by the paladin.
Now of course in Abyssea, which is the main endgame zone at the moment, most jobs dont need to cover since they can do great damage and have a better chance of surviving with High HP, High Damage and Whms Cure Bombing. So what would make paladin stand out again without reducing others in any way and keep the game balanced?
Damage Reduction Traits. +Defense is not bad but at higher levels that bit of extra defense doesn't do much to help paladin's side, but with up to 25% damage reduction. pld would be more useful to tank.
Say a monk is fighting and takes 600 damage from a hit, now paladin just with the traits take 450 damage. in 5 hits mnk took 3000 Dmg and pld took 2250 dmg, meaning it took one less hit than normal
Once the game moves out of aby pld will be again be a great tank, considering if the mobs can devastate other jobs via tp spam or spell spam. What pld does need though is a hp/mp/mdt boost. And along with that perhaps an ability to take Dmg almost like manawall but in the plds case 1/3 the damage is taken from mp instead of hp. Make it a sort of stance or something. Or a merit ability.
I guess pld is the only job that can wear PDT and MDT gearOnce the game moves out of aby pld will be again be a great tank, considering if the mobs can devastate other jobs via tp spam or spell spam.
Alright, time to throw out an idea of my own.
Seeing as how the playerbase trend has shifted towards emphasis on DD'ing, it makes sense to continue that route. DD'ing has been just as much a factor in tanking as staying alive. That aspect became blatant with the introduction of Atonement (and the MNK tank in abyssea... although they were tanking things like salvage bosses in the past.)
So as a means of keeping PLD competant in it's own field, upping damage is the only realistic way to do it (besides the nerf bat.) Almace helps immensely with this, and while I personally think it's good enough to justify a PLD being in a party/alliance, others may not share the sentiment.
Anywho... on to the idea.
How about something along the lines of a job trait or ability that reduces weapon delay based on enmity? Something on par with NIN's tier of Dual Wield or MNK's Martial Arts traits.
But if that sounds overpowered, there could be a stipulation like if you fall below 50% or 75% HP, the trait is inactive. Said stipulation gives us incentive to use our magic (along with dmg reduction gear), rather than wait for the WHM to take notice and Cure V you. It also makes enmity spiking JA's more useful.
Just a thought.
it's not a paladin problem.. it's a ffxi problem.
maybe if they gimped counter and retaliation hard, people would have less incentive to use dd's as tanks.. but even then.. why not use a ninja?
so now you either need mobs that spam aoe, or swing crazy fast to tear down shadows. if it spams aoe then why bother with a tank. your pt is still getting wrecked.
and if it swings crazy fast, that's just more opportunities for counter or retaliation to proc, so you better have gimped those already. you should probably also make sure the mob hits crazy hard so ONLY a pld can survive it. cuz if any job that outdmgs pld can hold hate and survive, that will be the better option.
it's just the way it is, you only need as much defense as you need to survive the fight, but you can never have enough offense. the mob could always die faster.
it's gotten so bad that i don't think pld can be made relevant without revamping the way the game works.. for example... change the way th works so it builds more steadily over time, but then raise or remove the cap on it. this would at least make an argument for drawing a battle out. NOT killing an nm asap. giving the thf as much time as possible to build as much th as possible. but then you also have to change the way loot drops. if a mob can only drop 1 of an item ANYWAY then you only need enough th to make it drop 1.. and again.. if the war, mnk, or nin can just SURVIVE while this is going on, while holding hate... then they are still competing for that spot..
that's just one random example, but the point is... it's not about making pld a tank.. it's about making HAVING a tank at all worthwhile. right now we don't generally need ANY defense centric job, and we'd only be hurting ourselves by using one.
Since Abyssea seems to be Paladin's main problem, I was thinking that adding new Atma designed to help the job DD tank in the zones would assist it greatly.
For example Atma of Monkey Grip: Allows the character to wield a 2 handed weapon with a shield. Along with stats somewhat comparable to high level atma like VV RR and Paladin would have a much better chance of keeping hate.
|
|
© SQUARE ENIX FINAL FANTASY, SQUARE ENIX, and the SQUARE ENIX logo are registered trademarks of Square Enix Holdings Co., Ltd. Vana'diel , Tetra Master, PLAYONLINE, the PLAYONLINE logo, Rise of the Zilart, Chains of Promathia, Treasures of Aht Urhgan, and Wings of the Goddess are registered trademarks of Square Enix Co., Ltd. The rating icon is a registered trademark of the Entertainment Software Association. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Online play requires internet connection. |