No.
People complained about all of the new battlefields the Devs were adding because they weren't worth the time/effort to go out and do them. Now, they are. Not only are scrolls present, but there are some decent equipment drops that come from these HKCNMs as well. And you know what the absolute most important part is?
They're fun.
So, if people want to get hung up on the fact that they actually have to DO something outside of Abyssea, they're welcome to cry about it all they want. Personally, I enjoy these BCs, and will probably continue to do them long after I'm done milking gil from the retards who refuse to get up and do the fight themselves. As long as I can turn a profit on them, they'll be worth doing. And they're really not even remotely difficult for a group with half a brain, so it's not like they're inaccessible.