A Simple Request from Thieves: An upgrade to Thief's Knife.

[Karbuncle]

Keep THFs knife the way it is so people don't have an excuse to full time it.

pfft, all the gimps already do >_________________________>

Sometimes in the main hand while offhanding a more powerful weapon.

[Atomic_Skull]

I understand the idea of Thief's Knife becoming a status symbol again like it was before the Sozu fix.. But that isn't really my plan. I don't want a 2.5% Chance at getting a dagger that doesn't suck.

You have a 100% chance of getting a dagger that doesn't suck with my idea. Even the NQ drop would be very good. The HQs would be slightly better but nobody is forcing you to try for those.

[FrankReynolds]

You have a 100% chance of getting a dagger that doesn't suck with my idea. Even the NQ drop would be very good. The HQs would be slightly better but nobody is forcing you to try for those.

Anything that forces me to sacrifice an optimal dagger / gear slot for a TH +1 item is just a side grade, and a waste of time IMO.

[Concerned4FFxi]

Lol, read my post no where in there does it say I fail to understand the tp loss, I stated that I find it acceptable. I think asking for another Thief Knife is too much and thieves should be happy with the dagger as is. In my post I stated why I felt this was ok. Read the post before you speak please I dont appreciate you speaking to me in this maner simply because you feel your side is justified over mine. At no time does my disagreement with you or your disagreement with me indictate a failure to understand the core of the discussion. Get it? Good. thx

[FrankReynolds]

Lol, read my post no where in there does it say I fail to understand the tp loss, I stated that I find it acceptable. I think asking for another Thief Knife is too much and thieves should be happy with the dagger as is. In my post I stated why I felt this was ok. Read the post before you speak please I dont appreciate you speaking to me in this maner simply because you feel your side is justified over mine. At no time does my disagreement with you or your disagreement with me indictate a failure to understand the core of the discussion. Get it? Good. thx

does anyone know what hes talking about?

[DebbieGibson]

Who suggested the JT that increases base damage according to how much TH+ you have equipped?

[Ezekieal]

WIthout reading the whole thread i wanna just say this is a great idea Karbuncle, same with your Evoker Ring suggestion in the smn forums.

Have a sequence of quests getting harder and harder to gradually increase the stats, sounds perfect.

For Thief Knife i would have the final quest change TH+1 into TH+2.

On the gimps mainhanding thf knife, i lol'd

For nm's

Daka +2/Thief Knife then after first TH upgrade > Daka +2/Triplus Dagger

Anywho fingers crossed that they implement this

[FANCY60]

thf as a trial would work but it has to be difficult to attain like the emp weapons where in order to get +2 th, u will need 100 carabosse jem or something

[Karbuncle]

Not that I'm against difficulty but why should a dagger with TH+2 be more difficult to Obtain than a game-shattering Empyrean Weapon?

Lets think logically here. Make it difficult so it can be powerful enough to deserve that difficulty, But at the same time, it doesn't need to be broom-rape. The Weapon won't replace anything we're using now full time, Its not what i want, Simply that it be a bit stronger so when we do use it, Its not a horrible hit to our DoT like it is now.

A lot of good ideas floating around. A Quest involving a tie-in to the end of the THF AF quest could have potential as well. A lot of Colorful characters in the THF AF Quest i liked..

[noodles355]

For nm's

Daka +2/Thief Knife then after first TH upgrade > Daka +2/Triplus Dagger

Am I the only one that held onto Auric Dagger for annoying/difficult TP move NMs?