Yes, you are overreacting. Monk can hit +100% Crit Damage, Pup ... can't. Instead of getting instantly defensive about your job's pride, realize that I was simply demonstrating that the raw power of a WS is only as important as the power of the job that wields it. Victory Smite is powerful regardless, but it's only "Brokenly omgz leet" in the hands of a Monk, much like Ukko's is "Brokenly omgz leet" in the hands of a Warrior. Similarly, Jishnu's can be as super powerful as it wants, it will still lack the "Brokenly omgz leet" title as long as Ranger's innate placement issues are still in play.