The Big Book of Adjustment Requests

[Catsby]

Update Assault, Salvage, Campaign and other events from ToAU+WotG to be challenging and rewarding again(hint; extra faucets for alexandrite). Rework the level caps for those events too so different levels offer different challenges and different rewards.

[Leonlionheart]

The warrior idea is copy-pasta'd pretty much from a Kingfury thread in the Warrior forums, where it was essentially shot down.

Seriously, bad idea is bad.

[atlanray]

White Mage Proposal:

Give us a scroll of Protectra V and Shellra V along with changing the group 2 merits to protectra a shellra potency.

[Laphine]

Please allow The five newer jobs to use the original relics.

The newer five jobs have mythics and empyreans. What's the big deal?

Game balance?
On dnc getting mandau example. Attack is the only edge thf has over dnc now. Give dnc a mandau and you basically cut over half the potential difference. As a THF i don't like this balance change one bit, and i bet the THF passionist community would rage/quit right there and then.

On the theory why dnc didn't get mandau we could say it was because dnc could not wear any dagger whatsoever. That was true until auric dagger was place in. Dnc always used mostly knives (high delay stuff). Auric dagger itself is a contradiction anyway. A dagger with high delay.

[Modoru]

and some aren't even useful capped at max skill (see: guard).

I'm pretty sure if Genome still played, he'd give you an earful. >:C Guard at max can be very useful. Just because nearly no monk has it, doesn't mean it's not good.

[Mizuharu]

Puppetmaster Proposal

A Puppetmaster at level 74 has 251 Hand-to-Hand combat skill. The quest for Asuran Fists is skill level of 250. Puppetmaster has no Weapon Skill Notorious Monster weapon skills.

I propose that they get at least this one. :<

-EDIT- (because I think it's called for before people reply... (coughwikigalkacough)
I'm well aware PUP would have NO NEED for this beyond Blue Procs. I'm well aware that Stringing Pummel CAN BE THREE MANED. I'm also aware that there are OTHER things PUP needs more. HOWEVER!

Check the PUP job manifesto topic. Camate already said that they will be fixing up the AI system to make cures first. They're tweaking other parts as well.

ALSO! If you check the RDM job manifesto topic, Camate said that they will be revamping Weapon Skill access for jobs. I'm praying that PUP gets tossed onto Asuran Fists, but I'm still going to post this atm since no one else has mentioned it.

[Leonlionheart]

I'm pretty sure if Genome still played, he'd give you an earful. >:C Guard at max can be very useful. Just because nearly no monk has it, doesn't mean it's not good.

Guard at cap is the same as Guard at 1, or so I've been told. Where is proof otherwise?

[Modoru]

Guard at cap is the same as Guard at 1, or so I've been told. Where is proof otherwise?

Well, what exactly do you mean by "is the same"?

Proc rate is much higher at cap -- unless that was changed and Genome's info is dated -- but by 75 cap, with guard capped, you could have guard proc many times in a row, or maybe quite a few times per fight -- sometimes guarding multiple-hit TP attacks could completely null out damage sometimes, reading as a "miss".

Or at least, that's what little I remember -- would have to go to his blog and read it for yourself.

[Byrth]

Genome's "tests" were far from scientific. Dude was, to put it bluntly, full of shit.

[Modoru]

That so? How come?

...Just send me a message on FFXIAH or something, don't wanna clutter this thread any more with irrelevant posts. :C