Figured I'd throw my 2 cents in here!
As already mentioned theres 2 sides to SMN, one is commonly and easily accepted due to general bias of 2005 style gameplay (SMN mage), and one is more harshly criticized and rarely accepted due to 2005 Style gameplay (SMN Melee)
The biggest problem with SMN melee is that, even with a B Skill, We lack the proper acc/atk to do decent damage, and even more-so we lack great weaponry, staves are literally the worst weapon class in the game for damage, behind even clubs/Hammers.
But theres another side to that. IN Abyssea a lot of our Weaknesses can be made up for via Atma and Cruor buffs, like our Low HP, STR, and DEX. Using atma's like VV/RR/Apoc help balance out our TP Gain (Regain+2), Our STR, and our Damage through crits, while also effecting our pets (BPs like PC, FC, and Ramuh's)
This really only works on mobs and NMs that do not possess devastating AoEs, or AoE magics like Paralyga or Silencega, for Obvious reasons, and the key to an intelligent Melee SMN is to know which fights would be more productive melee, and which would be more productive Mage.
-----------------------------=====================================
Now on the Mage side.
The Mage aspect of SMN comes from its support job, WHM or SCH. The biggest problem with Mage role is that Cure IV rarely cuts it these days, and any WHM should already be doing this task, better than you. SMN mage-Aspect really only works if you're with crummy mages, or are the single mage in your party.
Cure IV's, and -Na spells are nice, And we have a slew of Defensive Support Bloodpacts like Earthern Armor, Hastega, Healing Ruby II, etc.
Problem is a lot of our Unique buffs (Stoneskin-ga, Blink-ga, etc) are being spread about to other jobs via SCH and /SCH. Which makes SMN use a lot of its uniqueness and SE is not really giving it back to us. Earthern Armor is similar to Sentinal's Scherzo, ergo not unique (though they do stack)... Hastega is our only true unique Buff still, even then its nothing a Haste-Cycle can't accomplish.
Both aspect of the jobs roles are based on archaic 2005 gameplay styles that stuck with a community reluctant to change, both have positives, and both are flawed in some ways.
when it boils down to it, the SMN job is flawed itself, Masters of none and Mediocre at all doesn't really translate well in an MMO, why bring SMN when xxx job does xxx better? etc.
Our one true mastery is Hateless Damage, and its that, similar to THFs TH, that has kept the job mediocre over the years. Its the same reason Elemental WS's are generally Weak, SE has an undying need to balance a job so hard it becomes useless.
Elemental Weaponskills have 100% accuracy, therefor they mostly suck and are unusable dribble, in the same light, SMNs Avatars provide Hateless spike damage, as such we lack any other meaningful aspect to the job.
Luckily for us, Fights where our hateless ranged damage is vastly useful (Voidwatch) are coming back to light. The SMN job is nice in a lot of ways, But it needs work.


Reply With Quote


