Quote Originally Posted by Hyrist View Post
Martyr?

No. These are not job defining traits, merely accents, bonuses to what they already preform. For a Red Mage, they're our bread and butter, piratically a necessity to be considered worth ANYTHING outside what someone else could do by simply equipping Red Mage as a subjob.
If you are going to choose the bad merits (I don't know about the others, but I don't know a White Mage that fully merits Martyr, and only a handful that merit it once) that don't define a class for some of these examples, you point won't be proven well. A White Mage is defined by having Shellra V fully merited. I don't respect White Mages that have had time to merit that don't choose to merit Shellra V 5/5.

Sure, some merits are debatable in how much they contribute to what a job is, but how many Dancers do you know that don't merit Reverse Flourish to full? Certain merits are part of what a job is, and saying that a job doesn't need its merits (which are easy to get anyways) to function at peak efficiency is a bit of a joke.

Maybe Red Mages don't merit everything the same way, but I'd kill for just one of Dia III, Paralyze II, or Slow II as a White Mage. But those are not spells White Mage gets to even have a shot at, because Red Mage is the proper enfeebler.

-

On Red Mage melee, I've seen Red Mages melee things in ways that spit on the image this thread keeps trying to push toward the devs. Red Mage's biggest strength is survivability, and whittling down opponents, but these days Red Mage is also pushing out bigger and bigger damage numbers too. But even then, there is a lot of buffing/debuffing done to make fights go smoothly. I'm sorry if you can't just melee a mob and expect it to auto-attack and win like a WAR or a MNK fighting something, but this is the nature of what Red Mage is. You have to use all your job's roles to the fullest in order to solo, especially if you want to solo things that shouldn't be solo'd, like mythical Red Mages in the days of yore.

There are legit complains about Red Mage melee, but given some of the comments (like saying Red Mage hasn't been given a magical WS) suggest to me that many Red Mages in here might expect to equip their nuking gear, a sword, and be able to outdamage a Warrior. It takes a lot of work and specialized gear to be a proper melee if you are a Red Mage. There is some good news for Red Mage however, as it has some very nice toys available for this purpose, like an Atheling Mantle.