Job Adjustments manifesto Discussion

[Alhanelem]

Anything that makes scholar more unique is good in my book. I don't want to just mirror what WHMs and BLMs do.

[Soundwave]

Part 3, geeze...

[noodles355]

Hey Camate, how come the Dev team decided to give you infomation to make three posts directed to scholars, yet you made one thief post? Scholar have recieved detailed and multiple answers to questions, sort of like a Q&A forum, whereas thief got one post, met with 95% negative criticism, hundreds of responses, and yet got no follow up at all?

I hope the silence on Thief is because the dev team was so shocked about how badly their ideas went down that they have decided to lock themselves away and try again from scratch. This silence better be because they are afraid of releasing anything else to the thief community untill they think they have gotten it right.

[Tarumage]

Hey Camate, how come the Dev team decided to give you infomation to make three posts directed to scholars, yet you made one thief post? Scholar have recieved detailed and multiple answers to questions, sort of like a Q&A forum, whereas thief got one post, met with 95% negative criticism, hundreds of responses, and yet got no follow up at all?

I hope the silence on Thief is because the dev team was so shocked about how badly their ideas went down that they have decided to lock themselves away and try again from scratch. This silence better be because they are afraid of releasing anything else to the thief community untill they think they have gotten it right.

Lol @ thf's complaining. When was the last time you saw a scholar able to perform it's job effectively in Abyssea? My scholar is one of my best geared jobs aside from pup and my naked 84 whm can heal better. That says problem to me. That's why scholar's have been getting a lot of attention.

[Seha]

/sigh
This jelly behaviour that is going on lately is becoming so silly...

[Karbuncle]

There really isn't a viable complaint

I agree, was just trying to explain where he was coming from.

I know all we have to do is wait, and they'll get to us!

[Sasaraixx]

I agree, was just trying to explain where he was coming from.

I know all we have to do is wait, and they'll get to us!

It's all good

[Sasaraixx]

Edit to myself - The SMN post wasn't too complicated so I posted a brief summary in the SMN Manifesto thread.

[Hayward]

I've only one thing to say to all the Thieves bellyaching throughout this thread:

Shut up.

You have no legitimate grievance towards S-E in their vision for Thief. You've no case for wanting absurd abilities just so you can brag about outparsing heavy-damage jobs. There is absolutely nothing wrong with Thief's status as a utility melee job other than it doesn't fit into the mindset of a zerg-obsessed playerbase that only looks at parser stats and nothing else.

[Laphine]

How about the contradiction of SE seeing us as pickpockets but doing nothing to fix steal-like abilities? And really, we never asked to be the best DDs, but being defined as utility melee job with tools that do not work makes no sense at all.