Pfft - Synergy and Nashmau Earring

Please, please, please make these sellable on the AH.

Ive been shouting for 2 days for a synergist to make me a nashmau earring. I went to nashmau got the waystone, got a silver earring. Eventually found someone to make it thats when I got the problems.
I couldnt trade them the stones so I had to take the pot. SOME HOW I managed to claim their Republic waystone and earring. (I still dont know how I managed this). In the end I put my waystone and my silver earring in the pot after 10 attempts we gave up and I didnt get a Nashmau earring. BUT now I had the additional problem of having a Republic waystone that I couldnt give back no matter how we tried. Now I have a Republic Earring that I dont need and no way of giving it back to its rightful owner.
I ended up giving the person gil for an earring I didnt need.