On Red Mage melee...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Supersun

Not in the picture above.

---

Look again. You're either blind, or intentionally ignoring what is plain for all to see.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Supersun

Do you really not understand what a logical fallacy is? You have given NO reason that those numbers were fake besides either 1) You say so, 2) your BG friends say so, or 3) Because Sam is a DD.

That is not logic OR reason, that is your personal opinion being treated as a fact.

---

How about inadequate testing environment documentation? I saw no gearsets listed for that alla parse, so until I see otherwise I'm assuming everyone was wielding ash clubs and wearing bikinis. That's not exactly compelling evidence for your case.

KC rdm sucks? really?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U3XfsPLAr3A

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5SVTg...eature=related

So instead of arguing what we were before (A RDM can do 80% of a GREAT DD in a merit party) we're now arguing that a RDM can out DD a naked MNK?

safefacegranite.jpg

In 2006, yes, Rdm KC sucked on anything more then a decent challenge. No amount of accuracy and sushi in the world is going to get that D rated weapon to land on even trash mobs

Seems like it!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Supersun

In 2006, yes, Rdm KC sucked on anything more then a decent challenge. No amount of accuracy and sushi in the world is going to get that D rated weapon to land on even trash mobs

---

Actually sushi and acc gear would so you're wrong again sir.

Assuming 75 rdm/rng capped club with no merits+sushi, the gear shown in pic, he would have had at least... 82% accuracy assuming a T mob with 330 evasion. Of course, I have no clue what evasion Jnun has.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Aurara

KC rdm sucks? really?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U3XfsPLAr3A

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5SVTg...eature=related

---

Yes, it sucks. Abyssea might break the mechaics, due to how crap broken Abyssea is. But the Attercotts are a miserable refrence for 75. Try hitting anything above T with that tactic 75. I have. Wif wif wif wif wif wif wif wif.

Still, it'd be fun to see how Kittycatty measures up against Zafire, though.

Out of courosity Aurara, what atmas was Kitty using?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hyrist

Yes, it sucks. Abyssea might break the mechaics, due to how crap broken Abyssea is. But the Attercotts are a miserable refrence for 75. Try hitting anything above T with that tactic 75. I have. Wif wif wif wif wif wif wif wif.

Still, it'd be fun to see how Kittycatty measures up against Zafire, though.

Out of courosity Aurara, what atmas was Kitty using?

---

I have no idea, i searchrd RDM KC and those came up. Your gear obviously is terrible because my rdm at 75 could have melee gear good enough to have decent acc with KC.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Aurara

Actually sushi and acc gear would so you're wrong again sir.

---

Maybe against that easy prey spider in that video, but against an actual exp monster (which is what I meant by trash mob)

Against Greater Colibri I calculate that a Rdm/Rng would be landing the KClub at ~70% rate eating sushi and wearing accuracy gear (with ~15% haste from gear).

Not as bad as I thought but still not going to beat Blau/Joy at the time. Not even close. Biggest deal breaker is going to be the lack of attack making the TP phase virtually worthless