Please Rework "FULL BREAK'S" effectiveness + other GA ws's like it DEV TEAM /wave

First of all kingfury, I'm pretty sure that nobody would object to your signature if it was (always) textless. Just saying.

Second of all, your watermelon analogy is slightly flawed, unless only a certain group of people may eat said watermelons. We'll say that this group of people are Americans, and assume Americans are more-or-less well-fed (while in reality this is hotly debatable depending on your standards of "well-fed," this premise is just for the sake of argument). What you are doing is roughly equivalent to encouraging increased yield for specifically only these American-only watermelons, while claiming that you're helping increase fruit (watermelon's a fruit, by the way) yield across the world. To put it extremely mildly, people are going to state that your claims are nonsense.

Third, if reason doesn't work, maybe this will deflate your head a little: the terms that you agreed to to use this forum essentially say that all your posts are belong to Square-Enix. So if you post about something, and S-E comments on it, and especially if they implement it, it stopped being yours the moment you posted it. You win nothing. Good day sir!

I'm incredibly confused by what I'm hearing lol ><;

Accusing me of promoting crappy threads in part by my suggestions is shear poop in a hand basket, but I think a "Thank You" is in order so Thank You for considering my concept "decent". / I think... lol

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zyeriis

King is a tad arrogant about it but, still. You're argument is that he somehow caused nonsense ideas to start spreading like wildfire? Hardly, those people still would've posted, there is no proof to say otherwise. Considering that you, yourself, have started 2 such topics, you hardly have any room to complain. "Store EXP"? Really? As if people not learning their jobs properly due to Abyssea leeching, is bad enough as it is. Course, it was likely a troll idea, wouldn't be surprised when you turn around and start flaming some one because they actually got some praise for an idea from the development staff.

---

You're Trolldar really sucks. That thread was a troll request from someone who no longer plays the game and couldn't post it themselves.

I have legitimate ideas for content the big difference between me and the rest is that I don't suffer under the delusion that my 12.99 a month buys me a spot on the board of directors.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kingfury

I'm incredibly confused by what I'm hearing lol ><;

Accusing me of promoting crappy threads in part by my suggestions is shear poop in a hand basket, but I think a "Thank You" is in order so Thank You for considering my concept "decent". / I think... lol

---

By receiving a gold star by the community team you became an inspiration to idiots intentional or not. You cant honestly tell me that you think you are free of blame for some of the shit.

Hi guys, please keep the comments on topic. Thank you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tamarsamar

First of all kingfury, I'm pretty sure that nobody would object to your signature if it was (always) textless. Just saying.

---

--------
The art was created for the concept, so they go together and I see no reason to change it based on such types of misunderstandings and assumptions.
--------

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tamarsamar

Second of all, your watermelon analogy is slightly flawed, unless only a certain group of people may eat said watermelons. We'll say that this group of people are Americans, and assume Americans are more-or-less well-fed (while in reality this is hotly debatable depending on your standards of "well-fed," this premise is just for the sake of argument). What you are doing is roughly equivalent to encouraging increased yield for specifically only these American-only watermelons, while claiming that you're helping increase fruit (watermelon's a fruit, by the way) yield across the world. To put it extremely mildly, people are going to state that your claims are nonsense.

---

-------------
Wow... you successfully dodged that bit of "clear example" and have replaced it with something else entirely... uhh.. hmm.. Lets try one last time.
The watermelon in my example would represent "Full Break". If you managed to rework how it functioned (the way the effects were calculated), it would possibly alter the other weapon based enfeebles in FFXI by in turn sharing those new calculations. I don't think I can put it any more plane than that... so hopefully that clears it up for you.
-----------

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tamarsamar

Third, if reason doesn't work, maybe this will deflate your head a little: the terms that you agreed to to use this forum essentially say that all your posts are belong to Square-Enix. So if you post about something, and S-E comments on it, and especially if they implement it, it stopped being yours the moment you posted it. You win nothing. Good day sir!

---

-----------
Yeah... thanks for clearing that up >< /stagger. Reason works just fine with me, it's the opposite of it that I'm not to keen on. Yes, I'm quite aware that SE has a very capable legal department that understands the laws associated with "suggestions" offered up by players should they chose to implement them, so you have nothing to worry about in regards to me demanding a check. That, and I'm not an idiot... no offense to idiots though.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mrbeansman

You're Trolldar really sucks. That thread was a troll request from someone who no longer plays the game and couldn't post it themselves.

I have legitimate ideas for content the big difference between me and the rest is that I don't suffer under the delusion that my 12.99 a month buys me a spot on the board of directors.

---

-_- Really? You're going to use the "It wasn't my idea" defense? Really? I can't even pity that, it isn't even worth pity. Can't post it themselves? You don't need to have an active content id for the game to post on these forums. Just need a SE ID (which is free). My trolldar sucks? It was a troll thread...you said it was, regardless of whether it was a request or not. Are you touched in the head?

And yeah, I'd say he's free of blame due to free will and all. He can't stop them, which is proved by the fact that he can't stop your idiotic ramblings either. In this case, I guess you're proving you're point though: because of his thread, idiots (you, in this particular case) are posting stupid things on the forum. No argument there, though he can't stop you, only you can.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Qeepel

Hi guys, please keep the comments on topic. Thank you.

---

-------------
I will do my very best Qeepel /salute ^^;

Even though ramblings do happen, I try my best to reply to each post out of respect(even when they are at times devoid of respect), but if it looks like it's continuing to steer too far off topic, I'll just let it fall on a deaf ear.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zyeriis

-_- Really? You're going to use the "It wasn't my idea" defense? Really? I can't even pity that, it isn't even worth pity. Can't post it themselves? You don't need to have an active content id for the game to post on these forums. Just need a SE ID (which is free)

---

No you really have to have a working content ID to post on these forums. And really I posted that when the servers where down to draw out the "abyssea is killing the game" morons like Krystal cause I was bored.

Quote:

---

My trolldar sucks? It was a troll thread...you said it was, regardless of whether it was a request or not. Are you touched in the head?

---

What the *** does this even mean? Are saying you knew it was a troll thread but called me out on posting it anyway?

Quote:

---

And yeah, I'd say he's free of blame due to free will and all. He can't stop them, which is proved by the fact that he can't stop your idiotic ramblings either. In this case, I guess you're proving you're point though: because of his thread, idiots (you, in this particular case) are posting stupid things on the forum. No argument there, though he can't stop you, only you can.

---

I would stop but he seems determined to avoid any responsibility in this case.

lol Tell you what Mrbean, out of concern that such foolishness will possibly get my thread locked, if it will in fact help you drop the topic then "yes", by offering up a (as you put it) "decent" suggestion on these general discussion boards I have in fact inspired others to try their hand at proposing their own ideas to the Dev Team. Whether they are quality ideas or not. END
Thanks for your feedback... wait... actually I don't think you had any feedback based on the thread topic... but no matter. /take care