How about letting us upgrade Thief's Knife with ToM

I thought I read awhile ago someone did some testing and there's really no significant worth to get TH past level 3. I mean it adds SOME to it past 3, but its negligible? I don't remember exactly. Anyone care to inform me? XD

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Infidi

I thought I read awhile ago someone did some testing and there's really no significant worth to get TH past level 3. I mean it adds SOME to it past 3, but its negligible? I don't remember exactly. Anyone care to inform me? XD

---

Some of the testing results were in this thread, a few pages ago. They were by no means comprehensive, but strongly indicative.

Ah,ok, thank you. ^^

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Arcon

Some of the testing results were in this thread, a few pages ago. They were by no means comprehensive, but strongly indicative.

---

If me sitting there for literally days picking on Mimas are any indication, TH 4+ happened all too often to coincide with me snagging an axe from the fellow to make me not think it doesn't have a correlation. Most times, I had at least TH4 or even TH5 for the drop to occur, with one case of TH3.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rustic

If me sitting there for literally days picking on Mimas are any indication, TH 4+ happened all too often to coincide with me snagging an axe from the fellow to make me not think it doesn't have a correlation. Most times, I had at least TH4 or even TH5 for the drop to occur, with one case of TH3.

---

That is not just not indicative, it's actually entirely meaningless.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rustic

If me sitting there for literally days picking on Mimas are any indication, TH 4+ happened all too often to coincide with me snagging an axe from the fellow to make me not think it doesn't have a correlation. Most times, I had at least TH4 or even TH5 for the drop to occur, with one case of TH3.

---

For your tests to have any sort of value they'd have to at minimum be like this:
1,000 kills with TH 0
1,000 kills with TH 1
1,000 kills with TH 2
1,000 kills with TH 3
and so on

Otherwise your findings are anecdotal at best. As far as I'm aware no one has done that sort of testing since the 75 cap days.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zagen

For your tests to have any sort of value they'd have to at minimum be like this:
Otherwise your findings are anecdotal at best. As far as I'm aware no one has done that sort of testing since the 75 cap days.

---

Fair enough. Been up there for two weeks or so farming elementals and stabbing Mimas in the junk (I'm a Tarutaru, after all) any time he pops, so...figured I'd mention it. I know the Huge Moth Axe has a truly cruddy drop rate, so I've been checking logs after each drop to see what level of TH I ended up with after a kill.