Concerning Einherjar's Requirements.

We understand it is possible to beat Einherjar under 8~10 minutes with certain jobs. We got it PUP, BLU and other jobs can solo/teamup, There is also a system called /Yell for finding members we understand that, That isn't the problem.

Einherjar 1~5 limit at 10 minutes, certain jobs can not win with this time limit.
Einherjar 6~36 limit at 30 minutes, group of this size does not need a 30 minute limit, seeing that there are jobs that can solo/team and win under 8~10 minutes.

Quote:

---

Here's a quick hint: you don't need to do Einherjar exclusively with friends. Do a couple /yells. Is the OP that scared of strangers that he's having such trouble getting 6 people? It's level 75 content. It's so idiot proof that you can take any 6 schmucks who microwaved their way to 99 via Abyssea in gear even worse than Sparks gear and clear it without barely breaking a sweat.

---

I find it real funny how people tell you, that you should play their way and if you're not, you're doing it wrong. Also with these trolling attacks; "scared of strangers" "handicap on choosing to few" "playing 1 job then ffxi isnt for you" you guys crack me up; You guys are soo negative, close minded and obviously don't read things through to know what to comment on.

TBH I do just fine with PLD + BLM under 6~10 minutes it really was just a thought, Though it seems I'm chatting with children. Good luck on your endeavors.

Quote:

---

The only handicap is you choosing to bring fewer people than you need.

---

Quote:

---

If you only play 1 job then ffxi isnt for you.

---

Quote:

---

Here's a quick hint: you don't need to do Einherjar exclusively with friends.

---

Quote:

---

Is the OP that scared of strangers that he's having such trouble getting 6 people?

---

All this trolling and I just asked; Could we please change the requirements so that one (1) Person can enter Einherjar with 30 minutes on the clock and not just 10 minutes. Finding Players with same interests in this event and many others are getting very scarce.

Square Enix has changed Salvage, Nyzul Isle, Assaults requirements and revamped Dynamis cause of lack of players and the level increase.

It'd be nice if they took out the 10 minute timer. It just doesn't need to be there anymore unless they have plans to expand the event somehow in the future.

Agree, the 10min timer makes zero sense.

I can't even comprehend the validity of why people would be against this idea. Has the community of FFXI gone so far off edge that anyone suggesting positive changes, especially ones like this to help a declining pop, that they would ridicule and criticize them to such extremes? I guess I shouldn't say community, its about the same 3/4 people for years now.

I personally just /yell and don't have somewhat of an issue, but still doesn't change the fact that this is a positive change given the direction of the game.

That's the thing, it's not a positive change to me. Time limits have valid good game design reasons to exist, and I don't think they should be nerfing every high level content to be easily soloable, because that just discourages party forming even further. What the heck are we playing this game for if we never want to play with others?

That being said: I was actually unaware that the time limit is different by the number of players. That changes things a little. While I know about people clearing it with the 10min time limit, the fact that more people get more time makes no sense. More people dont' need more time- So I would suggest a compromise and adjust it to be 15 minutes for everyone. 30 minutes is far more than should be necessary so giving solo players that time limit would trivialize the content more.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Krashport

Though it seems I'm chatting with children. Good luck on your endeavors.

All this trolling and I just asked; Could we please change the requirements so that one (1) Person can enter Einherjar with 30 minutes on the clock and not just 10 minutes. Finding Players with same interests in this event and many others are getting very scarce.

Square Enix has changed Salvage, Nyzul Isle, Assaults requirements and revamped Dynamis cause of lack of players and the level increase.

---

Same old crap. Someone puts out an opinion. Someone else disagrees. Original person calls people "trolls" for disagreeing, and resorts to name calling. Grow up.

Your statement that finding players interested in doing this event is utter nonsense. I put together an Einherjar group, I get at least 6 people in a matter of minutes. My guess is that you just didn't actually try.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PlumbGame

I can't even comprehend the validity of why people would be against this idea. Has the community of FFXI gone so far off edge that anyone suggesting positive changes, especially ones like this to help a declining pop, that they would ridicule and criticize them to such extremes? I guess I shouldn't say community, its about the same 3/4 people for years now.

I personally just /yell and don't have somewhat of an issue, but still doesn't change the fact that this is a positive change given the direction of the game.

---

Because it introduces a problem (people waiting to enter an instanced battlefield) in order to solve a non-issue (people who don't want to bother even trying to put together an Einherjar group).

There are only 3 chambers viable for ichor farming. Each can only contain 1 group at a time. If the 20 people on Carbuncle each try to occupy one of these chambers solo without even putting in the minimal amount of effort to team up, they're gonna tie it up for 10-20 minutes each, locking out other people and leading to lines. It happens already in Salvage. But for Salvage and Assault there is actually a good reason to allow solo entry. Salvage because people are competing for a non-shared resource (Alexandrite), Assault because it can be difficult putting together an Assault group due to the rank requirements.

Okay. You many now proceed with the personal attacks and accusations of trolling because I disagreed with you.

I mean, for God's sake, Einherjar is the easiest part of making a mythic. If you're having this much trouble in Einherjar, how in God's name do you get through Assault? Or Nyzul tokens?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zarchery

Because it introduces a problem (people waiting to enter an instanced battlefield) in order to solve a non-issue (people who don't want to bother even trying to put together an Einherjar group).

There are only 3 chambers viable for ichor farming. Each can only contain 1 group at a time. If the 20 people on Carbuncle each try to occupy one of these chambers solo without even putting in the minimal amount of effort to team up, they're gonna tie it up for 10-20 minutes each, locking out other people and leading to lines. It happens already in Salvage. But for Salvage and Assault there is actually a good reason to allow solo entry. Salvage because people are competing for a non-shared resource (Alexandrite), Assault because it can be difficult putting together an Assault group due to the rank requirements.

Okay. You many now proceed with the personal attacks and accusations of trolling because I disagreed with you.

---

The least you could do is not look like a hypocrit with your last comment. The irony in it is funny though.
I didn't see anyone saying that Einherjar was the hardest part of the mythic. I may be mistaken though. You claim it's the easiest part of the mythic anyways, so what's wrong with making it 30 mins for 1 person again? Apparently everyone on a server is making mythics, all wanting to do them at the exact same time, therefore increasing the timer to 30mins for 1 person rather than 10mins, just in case they accidentally go over the 10min timer will cause chaos among a server where now people are always stuck in this horrific situation of not being able to enter. I must be super luck the group I bring in each morning on sylph has no competition, it sounds like all people are doing is Einherjar all day.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PlumbGame

The least you could do is not look like a hypocrit with your last comment. The irony in it is funny though.
I didn't see anyone saying that Einherjar was the hardest part of the mythic. I may be mistaken though. You claim it's the easiest part of the mythic anyways, so what's wrong with making it 30 mins for 1 person again? Apparently everyone on a server is making mythics, all wanting to do them at the exact same time, therefore increasing the timer to 30mins for 1 person rather than 10mins, just in case they accidentally go over the 10min timer will cause chaos among a server where now people are always stuck in this horrific situation of not being able to enter. I must be super luck the group I bring in each morning on sylph has no competition, it sounds like all people are doing is Einherjar all day.

---

His reaction is reasonable to me given the way this thread went. You don't call people names just because they disagreed with you. At best, that's an ad hominiem (however you spell it) fallacy, that is the "Attacking the person" fallacy where an argument is countered by personal criticism rather than any of the merits of the argument itself.