Red !! 100%

[Twiglet]

While fighting adze earlier today we got red, but no key item was rewarded (no deaths, unclaim, already having KI, etc). Is this a bug or am I wrong in thinking red!! is 100%?

[Arcon]

It should be 100%, but not sure what else could have gone wrong. Maybe someone else claimed it first? Claim counts, not aggro. Are you absolutely sure it didn't deaggro, and the person who claimed it was not dead or out of zone? Or was the person who claimed it talking to flux or otherwise interacting with an NPC? I'm not even sure if NPC interaction even prevents it, but no idea what else could cause it at this point.

[Sarick]

Did you steal the mob from someone else who claimed it first then disengaged to make it go yellow?

There was a Japanese player that would grab NM's and attack the other mobs while they had hate from a NM so people would attempt to grab the NM. Problem was unless the player who claimed first died/zoned they'd still get the KI.

A LS I was in claimed tunga from a player who said it wasn't claimed. She appeared to be doing AOE chest farming. After we killed it the player said thank you for KI and left. She basically used us to kill it for the KI.

[Thoraeon]

It isn't 100%. I have had this happen to me as well, and I have a friend who had the same thing happen as well. Mine happened on a pop nm, so I know noone touched it beforehand.

Just have to get a new one and kill again.

[Twiglet]

Nono, there was no stealing going on :) Must just be a really high % attached to red. Cheers for the clarification!

[Arcon]

It isn't 100%.

I'm very certain that it is 100%, as certain as I can be about anything in this game.

[Thoraeon]

I'm very certain that it is 100%, as certain as I can be about anything in this game.
Just like how you need 26% haste in gear to reach the 25% gear haste cap?

If it were 100%, this thread would not exist. Because SE has to deal with binary rules/coding, it is probably something like 1023/1024. There may be some weird results if they set it exactly to 100%, so they set it to something ridiculously close to 100% to try to compensate.

[Arcon]

Just like how you need 26% haste in gear to reach the 25% gear haste cap?

That's a display error, not a math error. You don't need 26% Haste to cap it, but 25%. Only gear doesn't display it correctly.


If it were 100%, this thread would not exist.

Of course it would, because players make mistakes or don't fully understand the game dynamics and don't know any better. This could well be one of those examples.


Because SE has to deal with binary rules/coding, it is probably something like 1023/1024. There may be some weird results if they set it exactly to 100%, so they set it to something ridiculously close to 100% to try to compensate.

This is not how it works, there are no numbers at all involved. if(mob.isRedStaggered()) { dropTheDamnKI(); }

[Kristal]

Of course it would, because players make mistakes or don't fully understand the game dynamics and don't know any better. This could well be one of those examples.

Did you check to see if you didn't already HAVE the KI? :rolleyes:

[Vicious]

Red proc has never guaranteed key item drops in abyssea. I've only seen it fail a handful of times out of hundreds of successful proc/kills, so it has a very high success rate, that's all. Probably a ~1% chance of failure.

[Elphy]

Agreed red!! does not equal 100% chance. 99-99.9% maybe but not 100%

There have been more than a few times we popped/red!!/killed and got no ki and/or atma

[Qeepel]

Hello!

Thank you for bringing this matter to our attention. Sadly, obtaining a !! proc does not seem like a 100% chance of obtaining key items, as found by the other posters. If you are continuing to have this problem multiple times, please fill out the bug report template and we will forward your information for further investigation.

Thank you for your patience and understanding.

-SQUARE ENIX MODERATOR