Great testing. That's dedication to use a Hymn to reset stats to get the same both both setups.
One thing to check on your testing is to only test on normal mobs. I don't fight many of the Small NM's but I've heard that they spawn at a variety of different levels. 53-57. I can't confirm this, but if it's true, that will screw your testing.
I can only imagine the agony of 100 SW's with keeping your HP consistantly at 100%.
I've only tested a few dozen of each setup for this reason alone. (although a friend putting regen on you would be nice)