Ok lets get this straight:
In the last few patches every DoL (with the exception of Fisher) got a buff or a role miner got Darksteel ore,Gold ore,Astral Rock (Used for the new Relic weapons mainly) and Botanist got Spruce Log (also used in certain relic synthesis). But when we look at fisher He got like nothing not even a single item,and tbh when ever a patch comes up i hope they add some new types of fishes to Fisher but they dont and even if they do they are lame (Navigator ear Srysly?). And in terms of gil hold on dont tell me that Ears make some gils. On my server atm its sold for 20k for HQ and 2k for NQ.
And quite honestly most of the fishes that Fisher pulls which are used for some Alchemy and Cooking recipes are easily fished by fishing bots and that alone makes a total non sense.
If we compared Miner & Botanist to fisher (alone without DoH help) in terms of gil making we find that fisher is pointless.
So what is the problem with SE? why are they refusing to add anything to fishing and constantly restricting his role for Food and (Crystals meh). Am not against that but look at it from a point where most fishes that are used with alchemy or cul are either cheap cuz they are fished from normal fishing which bots enjoys it.
Oh and just wait we do have Legandary fishes but still SE refuse to put them in the game why i really dont know.
Here are the legandry fishes:
Saltwaterfare

Freshwaterfare:

Ideas from a Forsaken Fisherman
1-Put a Repeatable quest for legendary fishes only kinda like "Inside the belly" from XI which gives certain legendary fishes gives weapons,armor,quest items, and materials from cutting a legendary fish by talking to a certain NPC. (I know alot of you will troll rage at me for this idea saying we dont need XI)
some may ask how does or will the fish give me a weapon or an armor it makes no sense?
well the "Megaldon" fish Description says it can eat a whole adult Roegadyen so whats the problem if the Roegadyen had an armor and you got it from him or a weapon, infact some fishes may swallow some items or material right?.
2- Fish ranking and Fish measurements (YES i want to compete in contests with my fellow Fishermen and LS members.)
3-Legendary fishes non stackable + obtained from fishing schools as a way to fight Fishing Bots (Dont u deny it.)