As in magical craftsmanship or just craftsmanship? Or... is it irreverent?
As in magical craftsmanship or just craftsmanship? Or... is it irreverent?
No, they will be either regular or magical crafting, and as result will benefit from either magical craftsmanship or craftsmanship. Which are they? I don't know. The game itself does not tell you which crafting recipes are "magical". None of the reference sites I go to have this information. The only way to find out is do enough of that craft with each stat maxed out and observe the difference; if anybody's done that, they haven't posted the results to the fan sites that I've seen.
I would imagine they differe, electrum I would imagine is craft and black pearl I imagine is magic, since they have melee stats/mage stats
Actually, to shed some light on the question I once heard a rumor that magic craftsmanship is for success while craftsmanship is for quality. I decided to screw around with this on carp, bsm, arm, gsm, and alchemy. I varied the synths and spent only about an hour or two with each and, after screwing around, found the rumor to appear true. Then again, who knows with this game?!
That's just my experience with some shallow testing.
but this contradicts with dev posts, and in game description, seems a bit off the in game description to be wrong.Actually, to shed some light on the question I once heard a rumor that magic craftsmanship is for success while craftsmanship is for quality. I decided to screw around with this on carp, bsm, arm, gsm, and alchemy. I varied the synths and spent only about an hour or two with each and, after screwing around, found the rumor to appear true. Then again, who knows with this game?!
That's just my experience with some shallow testing.
The dev post was from forever ago (if you are referencing what I think you are.) Either way, it was just my experience and the odds are that, based on the randomness that this game seems to possess, I could probably retest the exact same way and end up with different results!
I wish they would either state what they are or do away with the over complicated formula.
I was more referring to Yves post of saying that they don't do that but one effects quality the other effects success
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.