problems with this gearing system

[Seraphor]

Precious tier:
Tomes/Crafted=460
Hades=465
Upgraded=470
Savage=475

Current tier:
Tomes/Crafted=480
Ruby=485
Upgraded=490
Savage=495

Notice the pattern?

[Nezerius]

Precious tier:
Tomes/Crafted=460
Hades=465
Upgraded=470
Savage=475

Current tier:
Tomes/Crafted=480
Ruby=485
Upgraded=490
Savage=495

Notice the pattern?

You're comparing the 5.2 tier to the 5.0+5.1 tier, while you should be comparing the 5.2 tier to the 5.0 tier.

Patch 5.0:

• Crafted/Titania: 450
• Tomestone: 460 [5.1 addition - Augmented crafted: 460]
• [5.1 addition - Hades: 465]
• Upgraded Tomestone: 470
• Savage: 475

Patch 5.2:

• Crafted: 480
• Ruby Weapon: 485
• Tomestone: 490 [Likely 5.3 addition - Augmented crafted: 490]
• [Likely 5.3 addition - New trial weapon: 495]
• Upgraded Tomestone: 500
• Savage: 505

The incorrect pattern in your tier comparison isn't the same as the actual pattern between patches.

[Valkyrie_Lenneth]

You're comparing the 5.2 tier to the 5.0+5.1 tier, while you should be comparing the 5.2 tier to the 5.0 tier.

5.0:
Crafted/Titania: 450 [5.1 addition - Augmented crafted: 460]
Tomestone: 460
[5.1 addition - Hades: 465]
Upgraded Tomestone: 470
Savage: 475

5.2
Crafted: 480 [Likely 5.3 addition - Augmented crafted: 490]
Ruby Weapon: 485
Tomestone: 490
[Likely 5.3 addition - New trial weapon: 495]
Upgraded Tomestone: 500
Savage: 505

They did break the pattern of having the initial EX trial weapon at the same iLvl as the crafted one.

Not really. Was the same in 4.0

Susano weapon was 320, along with crafted. Tome 330, raid 340, wep 345

4.2

Byakko was 355, crafted 350, tome 360, upgraded 370, wep 375 for raid.

[ReviaInfantry]

I am infuriated that the work of the godsmith Gerolt, which took me few days to collect tombstones, dwell into numerous dungeons and trials, and gathering mats that are exceptionally rare... Is vastly inferior to what I collected and buy from the tomb vendor now.

/s

Btw e8s shoulda give iL505 and thou shall aim for that.

[Nezerius]

Not really. Was the same in 4.0

Susano weapon was 320, along with crafted. Tome 330, raid 340, wep 345

4.2

Byakko was 355, crafted 350, tome 360, upgraded 370, wep 375 for raid.

The guy I quoted was comparing the previous tier to the current tier, and how those two specific tiers showed a pattern of the EX trial weapon being higher than the crafted weapon. Edited my previous post for better wording.

[Liam_Harper]

Ruby EX weapons can't be anything below 385 really or crafted would make it obsolete. It already nearly does.

Crafted is an utter joke to make now. I made an entire 480 set on day one. It can even be pentamelded and materia rains from the sky nowadays. It would be silly if the only gear drop from the EX trial of this patch was worse than something we can throw together in 40 sec with a few easily obtained mats.

[Nedkel]

Thats why eso has best gear system.

[Kraniel]

I have to agree that i'm a bit tired of having to "update" my gear so often. For example if an update has 6 new dungeons/raids, i would prefer most of them to give gear that has about the same iLvl as the previous content, and maybe two of them awarding higher iLvl gear.
Eden & tomestones, which i consider to be 5.2's "easy" content, respectively award 480 iLvl and 490 iLvl gear, which is already higher than the gear you get with the hardest content possible of the last update (Eden Savage & Hades Savage).
For me, this is where the problem lies. For example, before this update, i really wanted to get the Eden Savage armor set, but now that i can easily get iLvl 480 gear, i'm not so sure anymore (i mean, i will still get it because the glamour looks amazing).

I think what is important is that newer players can have access to the hardest content in a relatively easy way, which is already achieved currently (you just need to grind tomestones and the easy content for a week, and you'll be all set).
However i do think that for existing players, it would be better not to have so many iLvl checks along the way, every time new content is released. After all, what is really interesting for most end game players, is to beat the hardest content, to get the best gear (as opposed to : having to grind easy raids to get the required iLvl to then finally grind end-game content).

I mean, i understand that SE adds these steps so that people don't clear all the new content in a week, but still, i wonder if that's the right way to do it.

[VenKitsune]

Only devalues the crafted gear if you do extreme and not much are sold because they are crazy expensive for the first month

BUt crafted gears main draw is that its ideal for raiders - If the crafted weapons are trumped by an extreme's weapon in the very same patch, content raiders are likely to do, then yes it does devalue them, i dont think many casual players would buy or craft the crafted gear just for their daily expert roulettes.