I decided to go with:
Tatanora Hull
Bronco Sail
Tatanora Forecastle
Tatanora Aftcastle
If it makes a difference these are the stat differences for you.
Mixed set
Surv 138
Ret 126
speed 54
range 84
favor 150
Tatanora set
Surv 120
Ret 140
speed 50
range 140
favor 120
They're fairly close in most respects except range, being able to hit more islands each trip was what decided it for me. However I haven't done the math or run it enough to have an idea of which is better (or if it even makes a difference).