You had me until this
makes you sound like the stereotypical Abyssea butthurt guy who does nothing but sit at a computer complaining about "Back in my day FFXI was hard...!"(It wasn't).
Maybe thats not who you are, but thats what it makes you sound like. Show me I'm wrong please
Why do you believe that those things are bad? I like Temporary Items as long as they don't over-due it... Even with them, They can make a hard fight (Botulus).
Temp items i think help people take care of themselves a little more. Spreads the responsibility around. Especially Potions.