Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 18
  1. #1
    Player Rorrick's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Posts
    61
    Character
    Lowen
    World
    Ragnarok
    Main Class
    MNK Lv 99

    [dev1017] Make Cover a Job Trait?

    I previously posted this idea in a thread in the Paladin job forum, but in light of the impending job refinements I feel this perhaps deserves its own thread, and that it may get some more attention here than in the Paladin forum. Forgive me if I've erred in the placement of this thread. Anyway...

    Instead of adjusting it as a job ability, why not make Cover a job trait? I see this as a simple way to make Paladin much more useful, or at the very least less of a waste of space.

    Due to the lack of information as to the planned adjustment to Cover, I'm going to use how it currently functions for the purposes of my argument.

    Cover's base duration is fifteen seconds. Unless whatever you're fighting is using an ability like Hundred Fists, or has exceptionally low delay, this results in at best a couple attacks being blocked. Most of the gear enhancing Cover becomes worthless as well, because it's very difficult to time the ability to coincide with blocking a spell or what have you.

    In a perfect world, Paladins would always be the focus of the enemy's attention anyway, which makes Cover very situational. As a result, meriting the duration up seems like a waste when you can shorten the recast timers of abilities like Sentinel, Rampart, and Shield Bash, all of which are much more practical. Cover's apparent uselessness not only affects the ability itself, but essentially wastes space in our group one merit category, where a better effect might take its place.

    And so, I propose the following changes: Make Cover a perpetual job trait, and change the group one merit as follows; decreases damage taken while covering an ally. Base of -6% damage taken at level 1, increasing by 1% per level to a maximum of -10% damage taken at level 5. (Whether or not this damage reduction would apply to the overall damage reduction cap of 50% or not is up to your discretion, but I feel it should be an exception to that cap in much the same way that Burtgang and Aegis bypass it.)

    I feel this accomplishes several things, ultimately making Paladin marginally more useful. It would render Paladin's inability to quickly generate enmity and maintain the enemy's attention a moot point. It has no impact on Paladin's (positive or negative) offensive capabilities, nor would it affect its ability to solo. It negates the necessitation of a complete overhaul of the enmity system, makes some old equipment much more useful, and adds more variety to Paladin's group one merits.

    On the whole, I feel this is a fairly simple, eloquent way to significantly enhance Paladin's usefulness, allowing it to shine a little brighter as the impenetrable wall I feel it is meant to be, without any drastic changes to the job or the game.

    Edit: Grammar errors.
    (14)
    Last edited by Rorrick; 06-05-2011 at 06:51 AM.

  2. #2
    Player
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Posts
    34
    I don't know if this would work to be "always on" since it might need a target (?) -- can we just have equal recast/duration, like a handful of other abilities? It could still be longer, like 5min (or more) ... and you could choose to keep it active fulltime, if you wanted.

    But this would also allow you to kinda turn it on/off at will. I remember Cecil! He did it until you told him to stop! :D
    (0)
    Rya's Killage Factory: http://www.happyhappyd.com/

  3. #3
    Player Rorrick's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Posts
    61
    Character
    Lowen
    World
    Ragnarok
    Main Class
    MNK Lv 99
    I was thinking Knight in FFIII style blocking, because targeting one person means you won't be covering anyone else if that person loses hate or dies. It also keeps you from being useless on things that spam Amnesia or otherwise prevent you from using JAs.
    (0)

  4. #4
    Player Avidon's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    San d'Oria
    Posts
    66
    Character
    Avidon
    World
    Carbuncle
    Main Class
    PLD Lv 99
    Job trait: cover
    I like it. To add to it though, you can have it activate as soon as the person with hate stands behind the paladin, the paladin will go into a lock down mode. It's defense increases but you are unable to act. If you need to act, simply move out of the formation. So you have an active cover at the ready, with the balance of a somewhat silence and amnesia effect. There also be a cool little stance in which the paladin takes :P
    (0)

  5. #5
    Player Setto's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    2
    Character
    Setto
    World
    Odin
    Main Class
    SAM Lv 99
    I personally think this is a great idea. PLD definitely needs some kind of change.

    PLD is a great tank as in they take very little damage, but the problem is them getting and keeping hate. They just can't build hate as fast as the damage dealers can these days.

    PLD is a great tank job but they need some more tools to make sure they are the ones taking the damage. Cover as a job trait would do this nicely. If not that perhaps some more hate tools.

    SE please listen up and make some changes to PLD, they are in need of some REAL adjustments so they can be more useful.
    (0)

  6. #6
    Player Lazus's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Posts
    45
    Quote Originally Posted by Setto View Post
    I personally think this is a great idea. PLD definitely needs some kind of change.

    PLD is a great tank as in they take very little damage, but the problem is them getting and keeping hate. They just can't build hate as fast as the damage dealers can these days.

    PLD is a great tank job but they need some more tools to make sure they are the ones taking the damage. Cover as a job trait would do this nicely. If not that perhaps some more hate tools.

    SE please listen up and make some changes to PLD, they are in need of some REAL adjustments so they can be more useful.
    you right pld need change. They do have problems keeping hate too, but even with this parties just don't have a reason to invite them. They have probably the worst, or close to it, dd in the game atm, which usually would be fine, but not with the capping hate within seconds and even if pld could there still are no reason to invite them over another job.

    As far as the idea of a cover job trait is concern it sound good on paper but just wouldn't work and still people wouldn't want pld over anything because a dd can just be cured bomb anyway. It wouldn't work because what if there more then 1 pld in the group? or what if there was 10? would dmg just not be taken by anyone in the party or would it just be spit between pld? Also considering you lose enmity by taking dmg and dd already can hold the hate cap easy enough, it just wouldn't be practical.

    Like you mention though the JA should have a lower recast time, look at shield bash for example, it does it every 5 mins (less with merits) does between 20-50 dmg (more if you have something like a Aegis) and doesn't always stun. This this should be reduced to a 1-2 min recast timer and less if merited. sentinel and rampart maybe push those down to 3 mins. Divine Emblem reduce that down to 5 mins to start.

    Still won't get us invited to parties though, there no reason for a "tank" when you got dd that can survive enough to be cured bomb.
    (0)

  7. #7
    Player Rorrick's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Posts
    61
    Character
    Lowen
    World
    Ragnarok
    Main Class
    MNK Lv 99
    There's a game outside Abyssea where MP is finite and some of the new Voidwatch NMs have clearly been to the gym. Obviously not everything needs PLD's unique level of survivability, but not everything should, because then you've created the opposite problem. Not everything should be dependant on one job (tanking, healing, whatever), just like like one job shouldn't be useless at everything.

    I agree that most of Paladin's ability timers (Divine Emblem's timer can only really be described as a joke) need to be retooled in the face of abilities like Counterstance and Third Eye. However, I feel that, in the interim, making Cover a job trait would be a good stop gap. It's the only ability that has always been essentially worthless, and it's the one thing I think can be adjusted without everyone screaming OMG BROKEN. While I don't think Paladin's offense is the worst in the game, I do think that any buff to it would be stepping on the toes of jobs like SAM, MNK and WAR, and pulls Paladin out of the role SE has been trying to carve out for it.

    Making Cover a job trait won't necessarily make Paladin more desirable, but it would undeniably make it more useful, and it certainly wouldn't make it any less desirable.
    (0)

  8. #8
    Player Lazus's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Posts
    45
    Quote Originally Posted by Rorrick View Post
    There's a game outside Abyssea where MP is finite and some of the new Voidwatch NMs have clearly been to the gym. Obviously not everything needs PLD's unique level of survivability, but not everything should, because then you've created the opposite problem. Not everything should be dependant on one job (tanking, healing, whatever), just like like one job shouldn't be useless at everything.
    You right there is stuff outside aby (thankfully) but still usually a mnk, nin or thf is all that is needed for most of it too, pld may have 1 maybe 2 of the new voidwatch NMs that make them desire again, but it still limited.
    How would making cover a JT be any ore worth it, pld still won't be able to keep hate, and if a evasion tank or a mnk with counter and a ton of hp can do it well enough to be cured bombed? (and this is for in and outside aby)
    (0)

  9. #9
    Player Rorrick's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Posts
    61
    Character
    Lowen
    World
    Ragnarok
    Main Class
    MNK Lv 99
    Quote Originally Posted by Lazus View Post
    You right there is stuff outside aby (thankfully) but still usually a mnk, nin or thf is all that is needed for most of it too, pld may have 1 maybe 2 of the new voidwatch NMs that make them desire again, but it still limited.
    How would making cover a JT be any ore worth it, pld still won't be able to keep hate, and if a evasion tank or a mnk with counter and a ton of hp can do it well enough to be cured bombed? (and this is for in and outside aby)
    You don't need to have the enemy's attention for Cover to work. You stand in front of everyone else and then regardless of who has the enemy's, you block the damage. Making it a job trait would just mean you can do this all the time, which would allow Paladin to be the shield SE seems to want it to be, despite its inability to draw the enemy's attention away from its allies.

    Inside Abyssea, where you drown in MP and have enough HP to survive anything, it wouldn't necessarily matter (but it wouldn't make Paladin any less desirable than it already is). Outside, where you don't have 30MP/tic refresh and 4000 HP, an unlucky string of counters is all it takes for a MNK to die, and you can't cure bomb people forever. From my experience, the new Dynamis NMs and some of the later-stage Voidwatch NMs have impeccable accuracy against everyone, evasion sets or not. Currently, Paladin is no use here because it can't hold hate over anyone, but with a perpetual Cover effect that wouldn't matter. It could absorb the damage while still letting DD jobs do their thing.

    Making Cover a job trait impedes no one, and makes Paladin, at the very least, situationally useful, which is several steps above "pretending to be useful IF you have Ochain and Almace", where it sits now.
    (0)

  10. #10
    Player Lazus's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Posts
    45
    Quote Originally Posted by Rorrick View Post
    You don't need to have the enemy's attention for Cover to work. You stand in front of everyone else and then regardless of who has the enemy's, you block the damage. Making it a job trait would just mean you can do this all the time, which would allow Paladin to be the shield SE seems to want it to be, despite its inability to draw the enemy's attention away from its allies.
    But cover as it works now you still lost more enmity from covering someone then you would if you threw a Cure IV on them instead and as I can see it be the same if it was a JT with this idea. And with it like it is now it near useless, this JT won't be enough of a improvement with how the OP describe it. It is a interesting idea, but would need adjustment, for example have decrease enmity lost when dmg is taken through it. Remember AoE in of itself anyone in range will lost enmity from the dmg as is, but dd will still get it back. honestly I which pld would have less to have to worry about using. beside JA we got a lot of magic, and then have to worry about sub job JA/spells too.
    I think it not a bad direction to go, but it not really enough of a improvement to add as is.

    Quote Originally Posted by Rorrick View Post
    Inside Abyssea, where you drown in MP and have enough HP to survive anything, it wouldn't necessarily matter (but it wouldn't make Paladin any less desirable than it already is). Outside, where you don't have 30MP/tic refresh and 4000 HP, an unlucky string of counters is all it takes for a MNK to die, and you can't cure bomb people forever. From my experience, the new Dynamis NMs and some of the later-stage Voidwatch NMs have impeccable accuracy against everyone, evasion sets or not. Currently, Paladin is no use here because it can't hold hate over anyone, but with a perpetual Cover effect that wouldn't matter. It could absorb the damage while still letting DD jobs do their thing.
    Have done really anything inside Dynamis since the change, but as for Voidwatch the groups I been in usually have a mnk or thf or nin for main tank, maybe a mnk or nin for a backup, a whm for heal, and a blm and or rdm, rest with melee DD. As it stands now basically the DD can tank too well even if one go down another can take their place easy as usually kite or tank it until the main tank recover.
    Also absorbing maybe 10% of the dmg would be out done by the fact that a dd can take out the mob at least 10%+ fast then if you had a pld in the party instead. And like you said a pld not going to keep hate anyway.

    Quote Originally Posted by Rorrick View Post
    Making Cover a job trait impedes no one, and makes Paladin, at the very least, situationally useful, which is several steps above "pretending to be useful IF you have Ochain and Almace", where it sits now.
    Perhaps, perhaps it would do nothing.

    To take from the OP idea if it became a JT it should lessen enmity decay. And that still won't be enough, but it be on the right track.

    If it stayed a JA then maybe when you use cover it would absorb all dmg from members of your party and a percent of that would covert to dmg for 15-30 seconds.
    (0)

Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast

Tags for this Thread