So the point of this thread is for players to post things that make no sense in FFXI.
I'll start off with a few:
1) The Job Rune "Fencer" doesn't get the fencer job trait. Hardcore fail IMO. This really could have been avoided if SE just changed the name of the job.
2) PUP having a throwing skill. They can't use it, so seriously, what the hell?
3) Shinryu not being a member of the wyrm family. Seriously, the monster's name means "Lord Dragon".