There's a number of things people might want to obtain from this, such as Ark weapons, or that other sheet of Adoulin music for their orchestrion. But any character who wants to get a chocobo masque +1 is not going to be able to obtain most of those things, because the 4k point cost leaves them with less than 500 potential points to spend (a total maximum possible of 4400 points, with 21 logins)
In my opinion, the masque and masque +1 should just be automatically rewarded after the 10th and 20th logins respectively. Alternatively, the 2000-point category should be scrapped and all of its items moved to the 1000-point category.
I really don't think there's any need to be so uptight with the rewards on this. It's not like you're offering Mog Bonanza-level prizes, here.