Originally Posted by
Cabalabob
Two main things I liked about ffxi that they didn't carry over to xiv which I think are big contributors to ffxi's life span are.
The menu system: this is something really different in MMO's, all the other big MMO's use the exact same system, that stupid little bar at the bottom where you stuff all your abilities and spells and everything. Granted in ffxi we mainly opt for the use of macros which are a similar system. But the menu system also offered an alternative which helped new players get on their feet and even some advanced players could use it to have spells or abilities ready to use that aren't in their macros. But the main point here is that the menu system gave ffxi a very unique feel compared to other MMO's. it felt more like a classic ff style game. All the big ff games use a menu system, is it a coincidence that the one game that didn't use it was such a massive failure it had to be remade?
The chat box: all other MMO's I've seen have that irritatingly small chat box in the bottom left corner that you have to squint and crane your neck to read. Ffxi had a massive chat box with huge font that took up the entire bottom of your screen! For me this was a great thing, it meant I could play on my tv (unlike other MMO's where this makes that tiny chat box look even smaller) and it made the game a lot more social, back when people actually still played ffxi I know I sometimes came on just to talk to people, It was like having a mini social network and it really made ffxi stand out for me. Sadly for xiv they went for the standard MMO tiny chat box... How they planned to make that work with ps3 is beyond me.
Basically the menu system and the chat box gave ffxi a really unique feel amoungst it's main competitors (WoW, LoTRO, KoTOR online etc.) but for xiv they took out these unique features that worked and followed the usual MMO style and for some absurd reason tried to be unique by taking out the auction house and any form of decent search engine, which clearly did not work. Ffxiv ARR, although looking better than what it was, is starting to look kind of like WoW HD, and I think for the future they should stick with menu's and a good sized chat box.