The cake is a lie!

[Malthar]

My Dear SE,

I have a question. If relic weapons are supposed to be the best of the best then why is it so that Aymur (99) has a damage rating of 89 while Guttler (99) has a damage rating of 88? Should not Guttler have a higher damage rating? Hmm?

Thank you so much, my dear SE. I know you will give my question serious consideration.

A humble beastmaster.

[Aarahs]

It does. Any other questions that only take 5 seconds to find the answer?

[Tsukino_Kaji]

It does. Any other questions that only take 5 seconds to find the answer?

Can the cake be a pie instead?

[Malthar]

Oh, here comes the troll march...

[Caketime]

The Cake is not a lie.

[Zagen]

If relic weapons are supposed to be the best of the best

When was this ever stated? At 75 most relics were trophies at best, this remains true for a lot of them even the 99 versions.

then why is it so that Aymur (99) has a damage rating of 89 while Guttler (99) has a damage rating of 88?

You talk about "DMG" as if it is the determining factor of what makes a weapon good or not. Don't get me wrong Aymur is amazing but not because of the damage rating.

[Xilk]

Aymur has a slightly higher damage rating than guttler, but the delay is lower on guttler. You have higher dps from guttler.

However, as Zagen mentioned, the high damage rating of the Aymur is not what makes its awesome. The Pet attack bonus, TP bonus and AFtermath which affects pets is what makes it awesome, as well as a very nice damage rating.

I think there is a very good case that you could have higher damage overall damage w/ aymur from the pet bonuses.. but its really hard to say.

[Babekeke]

If relic weapons are supposed to be the best of the best then why is it so that...

BLMs don't nuke in lolClaustrum?

WHMs don't cure in Mjollnir?

DRGs are only classed as an awesome DD if they have mythic?

Ukon WAR beats Bravura WAR on just about everything?

[SNK]

My Dear SE,

I have a question. If relic weapons are supposed to be the best of the best then why is it so that Aymur (99) has a damage rating of 89 while Guttler (99) has a damage rating of 88? Should not Guttler have a higher damage rating? Hmm?

Thank you so much, my dear SE. I know you will give my question serious consideration.

A humble beastmaster.

Because doing 9k Ruinators outside of Abyessa with a Guttler doesn't make it a good weapon.

Next!

[Babekeke]

Because doing 9k Ruinators outside of Abyessa with a Guttler doesn't make it a good weapon.

Next!

I like how you think that is even a valid response.

9k ruinators on Too Weak mobs?
9k ruinators in Legion?

A sentence needs context.