LS starting VW. No temps. Good PLD and so-so DD. Augmenting the PLD defense capabilities might end up being more useful than augmenting his offensive capabilities. That cactaur NM in altepa comes to mind. VW is still a challenge when people can't pop fanatics left and right.
Again not meaning to pick fights but there are times where a different strategy than what is popular will work for a group that has a different makeup than most.
Personally I still will likely end up in DD party rolling tacticians/chaos/misers type rolls. But I'd never say an roll is totally useless unless it clearly couldn't add anything to anyone (former Gallants roll fell in that category). We could argue that most BRD songs are useless too since they only sing a small selection for the most part as well.
If we get a 3rd roll I can see Healer's roll/Gallants roll/Tacticians roll helping me solo COR/DNC in Dynamis for some of those relic+2 quests.