Tested this outside abyssea
W/ Scythe
It is Guillotine Version 3
The bad
The DMG i found wasn't that much higher than Guillotine
Doesn't really compete vs Torclever
The Good
It restores ALOT of Mp i was getting 200-300 mp back a WS (100% tp 1.5-2k DMG)
imo just as a way to regain Mp it's good it's just sad that it's not that much better than guillotine DMG wise
Great sword WS
The bad
Weaker than torcleaver
The Good
Stronger than Spinning slash
w/ Souleater it puts out a huge amount of DMG (more than Torclever ^^)
Overall this fills a gap that was missing so imo is pretty win.
Summary The WS DMG wise doesn't beat empyrean but are useful and we can finally say good bye to guillotine lol.
As a side note when capped the mods are 85% INT Scythe and 85% STR Great sword (going on the merit info)