Search:

and you traded it back to both the guild master AND then to her again? then rezoned/game-day before re-trading it to her again second time? if still not getting results, report bug in forums here....

You went back to the mithra in Jeuno and talked to her again? and re-traded the +1 shield to her? Had to wait til next game day to do those too. This wasthe part i didnt do and irked me til i went...